Canal Structure Automation Rules Using an Accuracy-Based Learning Classifier System, a Genetic Algorithm, and a Hydraulic Simulation Model. II: Results

An accuracy-based learning classifier system (XCS), as described in a companion paper (Part I: Design), was developed and evaluated to produce operational rules for canal gate structures. The XCS was applied together with a genetic algorithm and an unsteady hydraulic simulation model, which was used to predict responses to gate operation rules. In the tested cases, from 100 to 2,000 XCS simulations, each involving thousands of hydraulic simulations, were required to produce satisfactory rules. However, the overall fitness of the set of rules increased monotonically as XCS simulations progressed. Initial fitness started at an arbitrary value, and rules increased in strength by better achieving operational objectives during the training process. Fewer XCS iterations were required to increase the fitness as the rule population evolved. Calculated water depths approached the respective target depths for variable water delivery demand through turnout structures in the simulated canal systems. The water depth achieved stabilization inside a dead band of? ±?8% of the target depth after applying different turnout demand hydrographs to each reach. The calculated depth was inside the dead band 92% of the time in Reach 1, and 73% of the time in Reach 2 for the constant supply experiment. The water depth was inside the dead band 100% of the time in Reach 1, and 76% of the time in Reach 2 for the variable-supply experiment.