Enhancement of tumor killing using a combination of tumor immunization and HSV-tk suicide gene therapy

Tumor cells genetically modified with the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSV-tk) gene in combination with ganciclovir (GCV) demonstrate a "bystander effect". Previous attempts to enhance the bystander tumor killing by combining cytokine genes with HSV-tk/GCV have met with varying results. The present study was designed to determine the effects of tumor immunization in combination with HSV-tk gene-modified tumor cells and GCV on tumor killing and to determine if the bystander tumor killing could be enhanced. Tumor-bearing mice immunized with syngeneic tumor (KBALB) prior to treatment with an i.p. injection of xenogeneic HSV-tk gene-modified tumor cells (PA-1STK) had prolonged animal survival (group 4, 56.4 days). In contrast, unimmunized tumor-bearing mice (group 2) or tumor-bearing mice immunized to the xenogeneic PA-1STK tumor cells (group 5) showed a mean survival of about 27 days after receiving an i.p. injection of PA-1STK cells and GCV. Control groups, which were either not immunized and did not receive HSV-tk cells (group 1) or immunized but treated only with GCV (group 3) showed short survival (16-18 days). Analysis of tumors for cytokine mRNA expression revealed increased TNF-alpha and IL-1alpha mRNA expression in group 4 mice. Furthermore, IL-2 mRNA expression was detectable on days 2 and 4 only in group 4 mice. Immunophenotypic analysis for tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes demonstrated an increase in macrophage (4%, p = 0.0001) and T cells (1.8%, p < 0.001) in group 4 mice with an enhanced T-cell response as compared with mice from groups 1, 2 and 3. Our results demonstrate that tumor immunization combined with HSV-tk/GCV treatment results in increased animal survival with enhanced immune response. Furthermore, the cytokine milieu observed in the present study can modulate the tumor micro-environment in vivo from one that is immunosuppressive to one that is immune-stimulatory.