Detrimental effect of nitride and aluminium oxide inclusions on fatigue life in rotating bending of bearing steels

Abstract

Rotating bending fatigue tests were performed on hardened AISI type 52100 bearing steel. Fracture surfaces after testing at a stress amplitude of 950 MPa showed that the Ti(C,N) inclusions which caused fatigue failure were significantly smaller than the corresponding alumina inclusions. The smallest crack initiating Ti(C,N) inclusion had a size of 3 μm and the smallest alumina inclusion was 17 μm. It was also shown that fatigue life was significantly shorter for a steel which showed cracked alumina inclusions on the fracture surfaces than for a steel which had non-cracked inclusions. Finite element calculations were performed to determine the driving forces of short cracks at Ti(C,N) and alumina inclusions. Two configurations were studied in each case, based on both non-cracked and cracked inclusions. The calculations incorporated heat treatment simulation and cyclic loading with successive growth of cracks. It was found that the Ti(C,N) configurations gave the highest driving forces for crack growth. The alumina configuration with a non-cracked inclusion gave the lowest driving force. It was concluded based both on experimental evidence and theoretical considerations that Ti(C,N) inclusions are more detrimental to fatigue life than alumina inclusions of the same size. It is their shape and thermal properties which make Ti(C,N) inclusions more detrimental than alumina inclusions. Internal cracking of alumina inclusions leads to reduced fatigue life.