Bereavement, grieving and psychological morbidity after first trimester spontaneous abortion: comparing expectant management with surgical evacuation

Early pregnancy loss is a profound adverse life event for many women, and increased psychiatric morbidity has been shown to occur after spontaneous abortion. Dilatation and curettage (D&C) has been the cornerstone in the treatment of first trimester spontaneous abortion over the last few decades. During recent years the possibility of conservative management has, however, been increasingly discussed. In a prospective randomized trial, we compared psychological reactions and morbidity, after either expectant management or D&C, for miscarriages of < 13 weeks gestation in which a transvaginal ultrasound examination showed intrauterine tissue and/or blood clots with an antero-posterior diameter of between 15 and 50 mm. Of the 86 patients included, 58 were randomized to expectant management and 28 to primary D&C. In patients randomized to expectant management, pregnancy products shown by transvaginal ultrasound disappeared within 3 days in 43 cases (74%), whereas 15 patients (26%) underwent D&C owing to retained products of conception after 3 days. At 2 weeks after inclusion, all patients answered self-administered questionnaires, including visual analogue scales, concerning their experience of the pregnancy loss, the present situation and concerns about the future. A brief anxiety status inventory was included. This study showed no increase in anxiety or depressive reactions 2 weeks after a first trimester spontaneous abortion when these patients were compared with non-pregnant healthy working females 19-39 years of age. Moreover, there were no significant differences in psychological reactions between patients managed either expectantly or by D&C.