Computer simulation of vortex pinning in type II superconductors. II. Random point pins

Pinning of vortices in a type II superconductor by randomly positioned identical point pins is simulated using the two-dimensional method described in a previous paper (Part I). The system is characterized by the vortex and pin numbers (N _v ,N _p ), the vortex and pin interaction ranges (R _v ,R _p ), and the amplitude of the pin potentialA _p . The computation is performed for many cases: dilute or dense, sharp or soft, attractive or repulsive, weak or strong pins, and ideal or amorphous vortex lattice. The total pinning forceF as a function of the mean vortex displacementX increases first linearly (over a distance usually much smaller than the vortex spacing and thanR _p ) and then saturates, fluctuating about its average \(\bar F\) . We interpret \(\bar F\) as the maximum pinning forcej _c B of a large specimen. For weak pins the prediction of Larkin and Ovchinnikov for two-dimensional collective pinning is confirmed: \(\bar F\) =const· \(\bar W\) /R _p c ₆₆, where \(\bar W\) is the mean square pinning force andc ₆₆ is the shear modulus of the vortex lattice. If the initial vortex lattice is chosen highly defective (“amorphous”) the constant is 1.3–3 times larger than for the ideal triangular lattice. This finding may explain the often observed “history effect”. The function \(\bar F\) (A _p ) exhibits a jump, which for dilute, sharp, attractive pins occurs close to the “threshold value” predicted for isolated pins by Labusch. This jump reflects the onset of plastic deformation of the vortex lattice, and in some cases of vortex trapping, but isnot a genuine threshold. For strong pins \(\bar F\) ～(N _p \(\bar W\) )^1/2 approaches the direct summation limit. For both weak and strong pinningj _c B is related to the mean squareactual (not maximum) force of each pin. This mean square in general is not proportional toA _p ² but, due to relaxation of the vortex lattice, may be smaller or larger than its rigid-lattice limit. Therefore, simple power lawsj _c ～n _p A _p ² orj _c ～n _p A _p in general donot hold except for very weak or unphysically strong pinning.