Case report: chromatid exchange and predivision of chromatids as other sources of abnormal oocytes detected by preimplantation genetic diagnosis of translocations

Preimplantation genetic diagnosis of translocations can be performed on first polar bodies (PB) at metaphase stage using FISH with whole-chromosome painting DNA probes. Here we report the use of this method in a couple in which the female was a carrier of a balanced translocation 46,XX,t(11;16)(q21;q22). This case unusual in that two polar bodies showed recombination events between the homologue chromosomes of 11 and 16 pairs, resulting in M-II oocytes with monovalent chromosomes having a normal and a derivative chromatid. For this type of case, PGD analysis on polar bodies cannot give a useful result, because, at the second meiotic division, either of these chromatids could remain in the oocyte, resulting in a normal, balanced or unbalanced embryo. PGD analysis on blastomeres can provide a solution. 11 previous cases of PGD of translocations performed by metaphase PB analysis are reviewed.