Probing immunogenicity of a T cell epitope by L-alanine and D-amino acid scanning

All residues of the I-Ed restricted fragment 24-36 of a snake toxin were individually changed into L-alanine and the corresponding D-enantiomer. Four analogs substituted with L-Ala at positions 25;30, 31 and 33, and nine analogs substituted with a D-residue along the stretch 25-33 lost most (position 28) or all their capacity to stimulate a toxin-specific T hybridoma. None of these analogs stimulated splenocytes from mice immunized with the peptide 24-36. Only the L-A31 and D-W29 modified analogs could prime a T cell response which, however, showed no cross-reactivity with the native peptide, demonstrating that T cell response selectivity can be deeply modified by mutation or configuration inversion of a single residue. Our data suggest that (i) the region 25-33 is the core of the T epitope that binds to I-Ed, and (ii) Y25 R30 and R33 contribute to the peptide binding by anchoring into pockets of I-Ed. In agreement with T cell priming observations, only the L-A31 and D-W29 modified analogs elicited strong antibody responses, just like the peptide 24-36, whereas nearly all other analogs were less immunogenic. All but the L-Ala30 and L-Ala33 modified analogs were recognized by a 24-36 specific antiserum as well as the native peptide. Altogether, our results show that substitution by D-amino acid in a peptide could be particularly well-suited for either minimizing the risk of hypersensitivity or designing peptidic vaccines.