Comparison of 41Ca analysis on 0.5 MV and 5 MV-AMS systems

A comparative study was made between the compact AMS system at the PSI/ETH Laboratory of Ion Beam Physics in Zurich with 0.5 MV terminal voltage and the 5 MV-AMS system at the Scottish Universities Environmental Research Centre (SUERC), Glasgow. Overall 34 urinary samples with ⁴¹Ca/⁴⁰Ca ratios in the range from 4 × 10^?11 to 3 × 10^?10 were processed to CaF₂ and aliquots of the same material were measured on both instruments.Measurements on the compact AMS system were performed in charge state 3+ achieving a transmission of 4% at 1.7 MeV beam energy. Under these conditions a suppression of the interference ⁴¹K is virtually impossible. However, samples with an excess of potassium can be identified by a shift of the ⁴¹Ca/⁴¹K peak in the ΔE ? E histogram of the gas ionization detector employed and a criterion for data rejection can be defined. An overall precision of ～4% and a ⁴¹Ca/⁴⁰Ca background level of 5 × 10^?12 have been reached.For studies with higher demands on the detection limit AMS systems like the one at SUERC are attractive: in charge state 5+ and using a gas stripper beam energy of 27 MeV, a transmission of 5%, a ⁴¹K suppression factor of ～500 and a ⁴¹Ca/⁴⁰Ca background level of 3 × 10^?14 are achieved.We demonstrate that both systems are well suited for large-scale ⁴¹Ca biomedical applications.