Fatigue failure investigation on anti-vibration springs

Fatigue failure investigation on anti-vibration springs, involving both metal and rubber materials, is presented. Rubber-to-metal bonded springs are widely used in industry as anti-vibration components giving many years of service. Recently a need to improve time and cost efficiencies has caused an unexpected early fatigue failure of the component with no immediate explanation. The required total fatigue life was 1.25 million cycles but only 0.7 million cycles achieved. There was an urgent need to investigate the causes of the fatigue failure and to modify the component design accordingly to meet the customer requirement and the supply schedule.The investigation, based on the actual fatigue loads, is carried out on these failed and modified products using a method of continuum mechanics. To simplify the simulation, a non-linear quasi-static analysis is carried out and then the residual stresses are superimposed to obtain the effective stress range to predict the metal crack initiation. For the rubber parts a three-dimensional effective stress criterion is employed to predict the fatigue crack initiation. The fatigue failure is taken as visual crack observation (normally 1–2 mm).The fatigue crack initiation for the metal parts of the failed component is predicted at 225 K cycles under specified fatigue load against total metal broken at 700 K cycles from the test. For the modified part the minimum total fatigue life for the metal parts of the component, estimated conservatively, is 2.1 million cycles against 1.75 million cycles from the test without any crack observed. The rubber fatigue crack initiation is predicted at 90 K cycles against crack onset around 79 K cycles and crack length 40 mm at 145 K cycles from the test. From design point of view it is important to optimize the rubber profile under this very tight allowable space to provide the maximum support of the metal interleaves and at the same time to meet the minimum requirements of the manufacture process. It is shown that this approach can be employed at a design stage for both metal and rubber fatigue evaluations on anti-vibration springs.