Charge-transfer in YBa2Cu3Ox

The charge-transfer hypothesis is shown to be inconsistent with data for YBa₂Cu₃O_x: (i) The two-step behavior ofT_c(x) (with jumps from zero to 60 K and then to 90 K) is not reflected as a similar, statistically significant two-step behavior in the bond-valence-sum charge of cuprate-plane Cu ions (as once believed), (ii) as a consequence of the law of conservation of charge, the derivatives of the layer charges with respect to oxygen contentx for both the Ba-O layers and the charge-reservoir Cu-O chains have the opposite signs to those predicted, and (iii) the charge-transfer observed for superconducting YBa₂Cu₃O_x is not sufficient to produce superconductivity, as demonstrated by insulating PrBa₂Cu₃O_x, which has virtually the same layer charges.