| Abstract: | Reviews the book, Countertransference in the treatment of PTSD, edited by John P. Wilson and Jacob D. Lindy (see record 1994-98036-000). This book purports to be the first to examine systematically the unique role of countertransference in working with victims of trauma. To help systematize clinical work with trauma victims, the contributors produced a theoretical model that attempts "to identify the core elements and dimensions of countertransference and their relationship to PSTD." The unique status of this book claimed by the editors is predicated on an assumption unexamined by the editors; namely, that the contributors have uncovered a new clinical phenomenon—countertransference to PSTD. This assumption rests on a second important and unquestioned assumption that the victims of PSTD suffer differently and more horribly than do other sufferers of the human condition. Haven't clinicians learned by now that suffering is suffering regardless of the external event that may have precipitated the hurt? If suffering is suffering, regardless of its provocation, then countertransference is countertransference regardless of the external events to which the clinician is responding. While this volume, by carefully delineating and systematizing a host of therapist responses to patient inductions, contributes to a better understanding of countertransference, it hasn't discovered a new clinical phenomenon. The value of this book resides in the thoughtful ways the contributors discuss monitoring one's countertransference and their compassionate and efficacious responses to the suffering of their patients. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved) |
