Primary repair is superior to initial palliation in children with atrioventricular septal defect and tetralogy of Fallot

OBJECTIVE:The objective was to explore the best management algorithm for atrioventricular septal defect in conjunction with tetralogy of Fallot. METHODS: We reviewed the cases of 38 children referred to our division (March 1981-August 1997) who had atrioventricular septal defect associated with tetralogy of Fallot; 32 (84%) had Down syndrome. Twenty-one received initial palliation with a systemic-to-pulmonary artery shunt; of these, 2 (9.5%) died before complete repair. Thirty-one children underwent complete repair; 14 of these (45%) had undergone initial palliation (mean age at shunt 20 +/- 24 months). Right ventricular outflow obstruction was relieved by a transannular patch in 22 (71%); 14 (64% of 22) had a monocuspid valve inserted. Four required an infundibular patch. RESULTS: Two children (6.4%) died early after repair; 1 had undergone previous palliation. Patients with palliation underwent repair at an older age (78 vs 36 months), required longer ventilatory support (8 vs 4 days) and inotropic support (8 vs 4 days), and had longer intensive care stays (11 vs 6 days) and hospital stays (24 vs 15 days). Eleven children (35%) underwent reoperation, 7 (58%) for right ventricular outflow reconstruction and pulmonary arterioplasty. Reoperation was more frequent in the palliation group than in the primary operation group (64% vs 12%). The single late death was related to a reoperation in the palliation group. CONCLUSIONS: Atrioventricular septal defect with tetralogy of Fallot can be repaired with a low mortality rate. Initial palliation with a shunt resulted in a more complex postoperative course and a higher reoperative rate. Primary repair is superior to initial palliation with later repair.