We report herein an efficient and mechanistically unique tandem chemoselective 1,2‐/1,4‐migration of the thio group in keto thioesters that provides substituted butenolides in moderate to excellent yields. Thus, α‐keto thioesters in the presence of stabilized phosphonate carbanions undergo tandem 1,2‐sulfur migration; whereas 1,4‐migration of the thio group has been achieved with the same thioesters after the treatment with Wittig reagents followed by BF3⋅OEt2‐catalyzed tandem reaction. The crossover experiments and the isolation of intermediates reveal a stepwise mechanism for both of these transformations.