基于共识标准的语言标度颗粒优化模型

研究语言偏好信息下的群决策问题.定义了反映群体共识的两个测度指标,分别反映群体内所有专家的一致性水平及专家的个人观点与群体观点的分歧程度;基于共识测度指标构建一种语言标度的颗粒优化模型,提出了求解语言标度颗粒最佳分界点的改进PSO算法,并给出一种对方案排序进行择优的群决策方法. 最后,通过一个算例说明了所提出方法的可行性和有效性.     

A Linguistic Information Granulation Model and Its Penalty Function-Based Co-Evolutionary PSO Solution Approach for Supporting GDM with Distributed Linguistic Preference Relations

This study focuses on linguistic information operational realization through information granulation in group decision-making (GDM) scenarios where the preference information offered by decision-makers over alternatives is described using distributed linguistic preference relations (DLPRs). First, an information granulation model is proposed to arrive at the operational realization of linguistic information in the GDM with DLPRs. The information granulation is formulated as a certain optimization problem where a combination of consistency degree of individual DLPRs and consensus degree among individuals is regarded as the underlying performance index. Then, considering that the proposed model is a constrained optimization problem (COP) with an adjustable parameter, which is difficult to be effectively solved using general optimization methods, we develop a novel approach towards achieving the optimal solution, referred to as penalty function-based co-evolutionary particle swarm optimization (PFCPSO). Within the PFCPSO setting, the designed penalty function is used to transform the COPs into unconstrained ones. Besides, the penalty factors and the adjustable parameter, as well as the decision variables of the optimization problems, are simultaneously optimized through the co-evolutionary mechanism of two populations in co-evolutionary particle swarm optimization (CPSO). Finally, a comprehensive evaluation problem about car brands is studied using the proposed model and the newly developed PFCPSO approach, which demonstrates their applicability. Two comparative studies are also conducted to show the effectiveness of the proposals. Overall, this study exhibits two facets of originality: the presentation of the linguistic information granulation model, and the development of the PFCPSO approach for solving the proposed model.     

Consistency and consensus models for group decision-making with uncertain 2-tuple linguistic preference relations

Due to the uncertainty of the decision environment and the lack of knowledge, decision-makers may use uncertain linguistic preference relations to express their preferences over alternatives and criteria. For group decision-making problems with preference relations, it is important to consider the individual consistency and the group consensus before aggregating the preference information. In this paper, consistency and consensus models for group decision-making with uncertain 2-tuple linguistic preference relations (U2TLPRs) are investigated. First of all, a formula which can construct a consistent U2TLPR from the original preference relation is presented. Based on the consistent preference relation, the individual consistency index for a U2TLPR is defined. An iterative algorithm is then developed to improve the individual consistency of a U2TLPR. To help decision-makers reach consensus in group decision-making under uncertain linguistic environment, the individual consensus and group consensus indices for group decision-making with U2TLPRs are defined. Based on the two indices, an algorithm for consensus reaching in group decision-making with U2TLPRs is also developed. Finally, two examples are provided to illustrate the effectiveness of the proposed algorithms.     

Deriving the personalized individual semantics of linguistic information from flexible linguistic preference relations

In group decision making, flexible linguistic preference relations (FLPRs) are very useful with the pairwise comparisons taking the form of flexible linguistic expressions (FLEs). Due to the fact that different decision makers have different understandings of words, this paper investigates the personalized individual semantics (PISs) of the linguistic information in FLPRs. Two optimization models are constructed to compute a linguistic distribution which is closest to an incomplete FLE. The FLPRs are transformed into fuzzy preference relations by using optimization models which maximize consistency and consensus of the fuzzy preference relations. The PISs of linguistic terms and subsets of the linguistic term set are obtained in this process. A group decision making model based on FLPRs is presented and a green supplier selection problem in automotive industry is solved by using the proposed model. The comparative analysis is presented to show the feasibility of the group decision making model.     

考虑个体累积共识贡献的犹豫模糊语言自适应共识模型

针对犹豫模糊语言信息下的多属性群决策问题,提出一种基于个体累积共识贡献的自适应共识决策模型.首先,利用犹豫模糊语言得分函数,基于经典的信息熵和相对熵理论,综合考虑同一属性下不同方案间的信息差异,以及各方案分别与正理想方案和负理想方案的信息差异,构建确定属性权重的优化模型;然后,提出个体累积共识贡献测度和全局共识测度,利用全局共识度进行共识控制,依据个体累积共识贡献度对专家权重进行自适应修正,构建一种新的犹豫模糊语言自适应共识过程.该过程的特点是对拥有较少合作的非全共识专家执行专家权重惩罚,而且专家权重的更新引起属性权重的自适应更新,反过来又影响个体共识贡献的累积.最后通过一个应急医疗设施选址的共识决策例子表明方法的可行性和有效性.     

Two flexibility degrees-driven consensus model in group decision making with intuitionistic fuzzy preference relations

A group of experts are commonly invited to find an optimal solution to a complex decision making problem. When the bipolarity of decision information should be considered in group decision making (GDM), intuitionistic fuzzy values (IFVs) have the capability to model such opinions of decision makers (DMs). This paper develops a consensus model in GDM under intuitionistic fuzzy environments with flexibility. First, it is assumed that the initial opinions of DMs are expressed as intuitionistic fuzzy preference relations (IFPRs). A novel additive consistency index is constructed to measure the deviation degree of IFPRs from fuzzy preference relations (FPRs) with additive consistency, where the non-determinacy degree of IFPRs is incorporated. The thresholds of the proposed index corresponding to IFPRs with acceptable additive consistency are discussed and computed. Second, the consensus level of DMs is defined using the similarity degree between two IFVs. An optimization problem is established by maximizing the fitness function, which is constructed by linearly combining the proposed additive consistency index and consensus level. Two flexibility degrees are offered to each DM such that the initial opinions with the bipolarity can be adjusted correspondingly. Third, individual IFPRs in GDM are optimized using the particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm. Numerical examples are carried out to illustrate the proposed consensus model by comparing with the existing ones. The obtained results reveal that the proposed additive consistency index can reflect the inherent property of IFPRs. Different with the previous studies, two original flexibility degrees are proposed to characterize the multi-granularity of decision information in GDM.     

Consensus reaching process for fuzzy behavioral TOPSIS method with probabilistic linguistic q-rung orthopair fuzzy set based on correlation measure

The paper proposes a consensus reaching process for fuzzy behavioral TOPSIS method with probabilistic linguistic q-rung orthopair fuzzy sets (PLq-ROFSs) based on correlation measure. First, the operational laws of adjusted PLq-ROFSs based on linguistic scale function (LSF) for semantics of linguistic terms are introduced, where the PLq-ROFSs have same probability space. In addition, we define the score function and accuracy function of PLq-ROFS based on the proposed operational laws to compare the PLq-ROFSs. Furthermore, we propose the probabilistic linguistic q-rung orthopair fuzzy weighted averaging (PLq-ROFWA) operator and the probabilistic linguistic q-rung orthopair fuzzy order weighted averaging (PLq-ROFOWA) operator to aggregate the linguistic decision information. Considering the inconsistency between the individual information and aggregated information in decision-making process and the demiddle of given linguistic sets tocision makers' behavioral factors, we define a new correlation measure based on LSF to develop a consensus reaching process for fuzzy behavioral TOPSIS method with PLq-ROFSs. Finally, a numerical example concerning the selection of optimal green enterprise is given to illustrate the feasibility of the proposed method and some comparative analyses with the existing methods are given to show its effectiveness. The sensitivity analysis and stability analysis of the proposed method on the ranking results are also discussed.     

A granulation of linguistic information in AHP decision-making problems

To be fully utilized, linguistic information present in decision-making, has to be made operational through information granulation. This study is concerned with information granulation present in the problems of Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), which is available in the characterization of a pairwise assessment of alternatives studied in the decision-making problem. The granulation of entries of reciprocal matrices forming the cornerstone of the AHP is formulated as a optimization problem in which an inconsistency index is minimized by a suitable mapping of the linguistic terms on the predetermined scale. Particle Swarm Optimization is used as an optimization framework. Both individual and group decision-making models of AHP are discussed.     

Consistency and consensus improvement models driven by a personalized normalization method with probabilistic linguistic preference relations

Probabilistic linguistic preference relation (PLPR) provides an effective and flexible tool with which preference degrees of decision-makers can be captured when they vacillatingly express linguistic preference values among several linguistic terms. Individual consistency and group consensus are two important research topics of PLPRs in group decision making (GDM). Considering the problems associated with these two topics, this study proposes a novel GDM framework with consistency-driven and consensus-driven optimization models based on a personalized normalization method for managing complete and incomplete PLPRs. First, existing limitations of the traditional normalization method for probabilistic linguistic term sets (PLTSs) managing ignorance information are specifically discussed. Given the potential valuable information hidden in PLTSs, a personalized normalization method is newly proposed through a two-stage decision-making process with a comprehensive fusion mechanism. Then, based on the proposed normalization method for PLTSs, consistency-driven optimization models that aim to minimize the overall adjustment amount of a PLPR are constructed to improve consistency. Moreover, the developed models are extended to improve consistency and estimate the missing values of an incomplete PLPR. Subsequently, a consensus-driven optimization model that aims to maximize group consensus by adjusting experts’ weights is constructed to support the consensus-reaching process. Finally, an illustrative example, followed by some comparative analyses is presented to demonstrate the application and advantages of the proposed approach.     

Hesitant fuzzy best-worst multi-criteria decision-making method and its applications

Best-worst method (BWM) is extended to uncertain situations, hesitant fuzzy best-worst method (HFBWM) is proposed by using hesitant fuzzy multiplicative preference relation for multiple-criteria group decision-making problems. The reference comparison of the best criterion and the worst criterion are described by the linguistic terms, which are expressed in hesitant fuzzy elements, of the decision makers. Weights of criteria are calculated by using score function. Using the concept of BWM, nonlinearly constrained optimization problems are formed to obtain hesitant fuzzy weights (HFWs) of different criteria and alternatives. To check the reliability of the HFBWM, consistency ratio is proposed. The advantage and suitability of the proposed HFBWM are determined by three case studies. The results indicate that the HFBWM, due to higher comparison consistency as compared to BWM, obtain plausible preference ranking for alternatives.     

A group decision-making model based on incomplete comparative expressions with hesitant linguistic terms

As a result of uncertainty and complexity for environments of decision-making, it is more suitable for decision makers to use hesitant fuzzy linguistic information. In this paper, a novel group decision making (GDM) model based on fuzzy linear programming is proposed for incomplete comparative expressions with hesitant fuzzy linguistic term set (HFLTSs). We establish an equivalence theorem of additive consistency between 2-tuple fuzzy linguistic preference relation (FLPR) and corresponding fuzzy preference relation. Based on this framework, a fuzzy linear programming is established to address incomplete comparative expressions with HFLTSs. It is more important that the proposed fuzzy linear programming has a double action, finding the highest consistent incomplete 2-tuple FLPR and increasing inconsistent 2-tuple FLPR to the additive consistent 2-tuple FLPR based on given incomplete comparative expressions with HFLTSs. By this means, a novel GDM model is constructed based on importance induced ordered weighted averaging operator. Finally, an investment decision-making in real-world is solved by the proposed model, which shows the result of GDM is effectiveness.     

基于重要度引导偏好识别修正的多粒度语言共识模型

研究多粒度语言偏好信息下的群体共识决策问题. 首先, 从个体和群体两个角度充分挖掘偏好信息下隐含的专家重要度信息, 基于个体一致度及个体与群体的相似度构建确定专家重要度的优化模型; 其次, 以专家重要度引导非共识偏好的识别和修正过程, 提出一种自适应的语言共识模型; 然后, 给出一种群决策方法, 确保在集结专家意见前群体达成一定程度的共识; 最后, 通过算例验证所提出方法的可行性和有效性.

     

Structural developments of fuzzy systems with the aid of information granulation

We introduce a design procedure for fuzzy systems using the concept of information granulation and genetic optimization. Information granulation and resulting information granules themselves become an important design aspect of fuzzy models. By accommodating the formalism of fuzzy sets, the model is geared towards capturing relationship between information granules (fuzzy sets) rather than concentrating on plain numeric data. Information granulation realized with the use of the standard C-Means clustering helps determine the initial values of the parameters of the fuzzy models. This in particular concerns such essential components of the rules as the initial apexes of the membership functions standing in the premise part of the fuzzy rules and the initial values of the polynomial functions standing in the consequence part. The initial parameters are afterwards tuned with the aid of the genetic algorithms (GAs) and the least square method (LSM). The overall design methodology arises as a hybrid development process involving structural and parametric optimization. Especially, genetic algorithms and C-Means are used to generate the structurally as well as parametrically optimized fuzzy model. To identify the structure and estimate parameters of the fuzzy model we exploit the methodologies such as joint and successive method realized by means of genetic algorithms. The proposed model is evaluated using experimental data and its performance is contrasted with the behavior of the fuzzy models available in the literature.     

区间Pythagorean模糊前景多阶段多属性应急决策方法

针对属性权重未知且决策信息为区间Pythagorean模糊语言的应急决策问题,提出一种基于组合赋权和前景理论的多阶段多属性决策方法。根据方案信息熵确定属性权重范围,并以区间Pythagorean模糊熵最小为目标构建模型并求解,以确定属性权重。定义正负理想点作为参考点,运用前景理论求出每一阶段各状态下的前景值,并考虑前一阶段方案对后一阶段状态概率的影响,求出方案链的前景值。在此基础上,以方案链的前景值最大和成本最小为目标构建优化模型,并将多目标转化为单目标,求解模型以确定各阶段的最优方案。以某传染病疫情防控应急决策问题为算例验证了该方法的可行性,并将多阶段决策效果与单一阶段的决策结果进行比较分析,验证了该方法的有效性。     

An approach to group decision making with heterogeneous incomplete uncertain preference relations

For practical group decision making problems, decision makers tend to provide heterogeneous uncertain preference relations due to the uncertainty of the decision environment and the difference of cultures and education backgrounds. Sometimes, decision makers may not have an in-depth knowledge of the problem to be solved and provide incomplete preference relations. In this paper, we focus on group decision making (GDM) problems with heterogeneous incomplete uncertain preference relations, including uncertain multiplicative preference relations, uncertain fuzzy preference relations, uncertain linguistic preference relations and intuitionistic fuzzy preference relations. To deal with such GDM problems, a decision analysis method is proposed. Based on the multiplicative consistency of uncertain preference relations, a bi-objective optimization model which aims to maximize both the group consensus and the individual consistency of each decision maker is established. By solving the optimization model, the priority weights of alternatives can be obtained. Finally, some illustrative examples are used to show the feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed method.     

Fuzzy决策中有限方案的群体一致性评价方法与算法

运用三角模糊数的概念提出两种有限方案的群体评价方法：１）根据个体驻向量提出衡量个体间一致性的相似度量函数,由此构造个体、群体的一致性指标,并给出群体一致性的定义,用个体指标提出由个体加权向量寻求群体加权向量的两种方法;２）利用三角模糊数构造语言评价集,并给出一种基于语言的方案评价方法与算法。     

A consensus reaching model for 2-tuple linguistic multiple attribute group decision making with incomplete weight information

The aim of this paper is to put forward a consensus reaching method for multi-attribute group decision-making (MAGDM) problems with linguistic information, in which the weight information of experts and attributes is unknown. First, some basic concepts and operational laws of 2-tuple linguistic label are introduced. Then, a grey relational analysis method and a maximising deviation method are proposed to calculate the incomplete weight information of experts and attributes respectively. To eliminate the conflict in the group, a weight-updating model is employed to derive the weights of experts based on their contribution to the consensus reaching process. After conflict elimination, the final group preference can be obtained which will give the ranking of the alternatives. The model can effectively avoid information distortion which is occurred regularly in the linguistic information processing. Finally, an illustrative example is given to illustrate the application of the proposed method and comparative analysis with the existing methods are offered to show the advantages of the proposed method.     

A Consensus Support System Model for Group Decision-Making Problems With Multigranular Linguistic Preference Relations

The group decision-making framework with linguistic preference relations is studied. In this context, we assume that there exist several experts who may have different background and knowledge to solve a particular problem and, therefore, different linguistic term sets (multigranular linguistic information) could be used to express their opinions. The aim of this paper is to present a model of consensus support system to assist the experts in all phases of the consensus reaching process of group decision-making problems with multigranular linguistic preference relations. This consensus support system model is based on i) a multigranular linguistic methodology, ii) two consensus criteria, consensus degrees and proximity measures, and iii) a guidance advice system. The multigranular linguistic methodology permits the unification of the different linguistic domains to facilitate the calculus of consensus degrees and proximity measures on the basis of experts' opinions. The consensus degrees assess the agreement amongst all the experts' opinions, while the proximity measures are used to find out how far the individual opinions are from the group opinion. The guidance advice system integrated in the consensus support system model acts as a feedback mechanism, and it is based on a set of advice rules to help the experts change their opinions and to find out which direction that change should follow in order to obtain the highest degree of consensus possible. There are two main advantages provided by this model of consensus support system. Firstly, its ability to cope with group decision-making problems with multigranular linguistic preference relations, and, secondly, the figure of the moderator, traditionally presents in the consensus reaching process, is replaced by the guidance advice system, and in such a way, the whole group decision-making process is automated     

Linear optimization modeling of consistency issues in group decision making based on fuzzy preference relations

The consistency measure is a vital basis for group decision making (GDM) based on fuzzy preference relations, and includes two subproblems: individual consistency and consensus consistency. This paper proposes linear optimization models for solving some issues on consistency of fuzzy preference relations, such as individual consistency construction, consensus model and management of incomplete fuzzy preference relations. Our proposal optimally preserves original preference information in constructing individual consistency and reaching consensus (in Manhattan distance sense), and maximizes the consistency level of fuzzy preference relations in calculating the missing values of incomplete fuzzy preference relations. Linear optimization models can be solved in very little computational time using readily available softwares. Therefore, the results in this paper are also of simplicity and convenience for the application of consistent fuzzy preference relations in GDM problems.     

On group decision making with four formats of incomplete preference relations

In this paper, a new approach is proposed to solve group decision making (GDM) problems where the preference information on alternatives provided by decision makers (DMs) is represented in four formats of incomplete preference relations, i.e., incomplete multiplicative preference relations, incomplete fuzzy preference relations, incomplete additive linguistic preference relations, incomplete multiplicative linguistic preference relations. In order to make the collective opinion close each decision maker’s opinion as near as possible, an optimization model is constructed to integrate the four different formats of incomplete preference relations and to compute the collective ranking values of the alternatives. The ranking of alternatives or selection of the most desirable alternative(s) is directly obtained from the derived collective ranking values. A numerical example is also used to illustrate the applicability of the proposed approach.