Terrain‐adaptive wheel speed control on the Curiosity Mars rover: Algorithm and flight results

NASA's Mars Science Laboratory Curiosity rover landed in August 2012 and began experiencing higher rates of wheel damage beginning in October 2013. While the wheels were designed to accumulate considerable damage, the unexpected damage rate raised concerns regarding wheel lifetime. In response, the Jet Propulsion Laboratory developed and deployed mobility flight software on Curiosity that reduces the forces on the wheels. The new algorithm adapts each wheel's speed to fit the terrain topography in real time, by leveraging the rover's measured attitude rates and rocker/bogie suspension angles and rates. Together with a rigid‐body kinematics model, it estimates the real‐time wheel‐terrain contact angles and commands idealized, no‐slip wheel angular rates. In addition, free‐floating “wheelies” are detected and autonomously corrected. Ground test data indicate that the forces on the wheels are reduced by 19% for leading wheels and 11% for middle leading wheels. On the ground, the required data volume increased by up to 129%, and drive duration increased by up to 25%. In flight, data collected over 3.6 km and 149 drives confirmed a reduction in wheel current, correlated with wheel torque, of 18.7%. The new algorithm proved to use fewer resources in flight than ground estimates suggested, as only a 10% increase in drive duration and double the drive data volume were experienced. These data indicate the promise of the new algorithm to extend the life of the wheels for the Curiosity rover. This paper describes the algorithm, its ground testing campaign and associated challenges, and its validation, implementation, and performance in flight.     

Improved Rover State Estimation in Challenging Terrain

Given ambitious mission objectives and long delay times between command-uplink/data-downlink sessions, increased autonomy is required for planetary rovers. Specifically, NASA's planned 2003 and 2005 Mars rover missions must incorporate increased autonomy if their desired mission goals are to be realized. Increased autonomy, including autonomous path planning and navigation to user designated goals, relies on good quality estimates of the rover's state, e.g., its position and orientation relative to some initial reference frame. The challenging terrain over which the rover will necessarily traverse tends to seriously degrade a dead-reckoned state estimate, given severe wheel slip and/or interaction with obstacles. In this paper, we present the implementation of a complete rover navigation system. First, the system is able to adaptively construct semi-sparse terrain maps based on the current ground texture and distances to possible nearby obstacles. Second, the rover is able to match successively constructed terrain maps to obtain a vision-based state estimate which can then be fused with wheel odometry to obtain a much improved state estimate. Finally the rover makes use of this state estimate to perform autonomous real-time path planning and navigation to user designated goals. Reactive obstacle avoidance is also implemented for roaming in an environment in the absence of a user designated goal. The system is demonstrated in soft soil and relatively dense rock fields, achieving state estimates that are significantly improved with respect to dead reckoning alone (e.g., 0.38 m mean absolute error vs. 1.34 m), and successfully navigating in multiple trials to user designated goals.     

Range‐dependent Terrain Mapping and Multipath Planning using Cylindrical Coordinates for a Planetary Exploration Rover

This paper presents terrain mapping and path‐planning techniques that are key issues for autonomous mobility of a planetary exploration rover. In this work, a LIDAR (light detection and ranging) sensor is used to obtain geometric information on the terrain. A point cloud of the terrain feature provided from the LIDAR sensor is usually converted to a digital elevation map. A sector‐shaped reference grid for the conversion process is proposed in this paper, resulting in an elevation map with cylindrical coordinates termed as C²DEM. This conversion approach achieves a range‐dependent resolution for the terrain mapping: a detailed terrain representation near the rover and a sparse representation far from the rover. The path planning utilizes a cost function composed of terrain inclination, terrain roughness, and path length indices, each of which is subject to a weighting factor. The multipath planning developed in this paper first explores possible sets of weighting factors and generates multiple candidate paths. The most feasible path is then determined by a comparative evaluation between the candidate paths. Field experiments with a rover prototype at a Lunar/Martian analog site were performed to confirm the feasibility of the proposed techniques, including the range‐dependent terrain mapping with C²DEM and the multipath‐planning method.     

Mars microrover navigation: Performance evaluation and enhancement

In 1996, NASA will launch the Mars Pathfinder spacecraft, which will carry an 11 kg rover to explore the immediate vicinity of the lander. To assess the capabilities of the rover, as well as to set priorities for future rover research, it is essential to evaluate the performance of its autonomous navigation system as a function of terrain characteristics. Unfortunately, very little of this kind of evaluation has been done, for either planetary rovers or terrestrial applications. To fill this gap, we have constructed a new microrover testbed consisting of the Rocky 3.2 vehicle and an indoor test arena with overhead cameras for automatic, real-time tracking of the true rover position and heading. We create Mars analog terrains in this arena by randomly distributing rocks according to an exponential model of Mars rock size frequency created from Viking lander imagery. To date, we have recorded detailed logs from over 85 navigation trials in this testbed. In this paper, we outline current plans for Mars exploration over the next decade, summarize the design of the lander and rover for the 1996 Pathfinder mission, and introduce a decomposition of rover navigation into four major functions: goal designation, rover localization, hazard detection, and path selection. We then describe the Pathfinder approach to each function, present results to date of evaluating the performance of each function, and outline our approach to enhancing performance for future missions. The results show key limitations in the quality of rover localization, the speed of hazard detection, and the ability of behavior control algorithms for path selection to negotiate the rock frequencies likely to be encountered on Mars. We believe that the facilities, methodologies, and to some extent the specific performance results presented here will provide valuable examples for efforts to evaluate robotic vehicle performance in other applications.     

Slip-compensated path following for planetary exploration rovers

A system that enables continuous slip compensation for a Mars rover has been designed, implemented and field-tested. This system is composed of several components that allow the rover to accurately and continuously follow a designated path, compensate for slippage and reach intended goals in high-slip environments. These components include visual odometry, vehicle kinematics, a Kalman filter pose estimator and a slip-compensated path follower. Visual odometry tracks distinctive scene features in stereo imagery to estimate rover motion between successively acquired stereo image pairs. The kinematics for a rocker–bogie suspension system estimates vehicle motion by measuring wheel rates, and rocker, bogie and steering angles. The Kalman filter processes measurements from an inertial measurement unit and visual odometry. The filter estimate is then compared to the kinematic estimate to determine whether slippage has occurred, taking into account estimate uncertainties. If slippage is detected, the slip vector is calculated by differencing the current Kalman filter estimate from the kinematic estimate. This slip vector is then used to determine the necessary wheel velocities and steering angles to compensate for slip and follow the desired path.     

Study on climbing strategy and analysis of Mars rover

To ensure the safety and efficiency of Zhurong Mars rover when climbing a slope on Mars, the forces of the rover under four climbing methods, which are normal climbing, Z-type climbing, diagonal climbing, and bionic wriggle climbing, are analyzed. Each method corresponds to different maximum climbing slopes. The experiments are carried out with a backup rover on dense and soft terrains to determine the range of climbing slope for different climbing methods. According to the slope, peak current, cost of transport, and state of terrain, the climbing strategy is given. For dense and soft terrains, the soil cohesive is 0.99 and 1.4 kN/mⁿ⁺¹ and soil friction modules are 1528 and 700 kN/mⁿ⁺², respectively. Specifically, normal climbing is recommended for low-range slopes, while Z-type or diagonal climbing are suggested for medium-range slopes, and bionic wriggle climbing is found to be optimal for high-range slopes. To ensure the safety of the Zhurong Mars rover, it fails climbing if the critical values are exceeded. These results provide valuable insights for human operators when planning the rover's slope-climbing actions on Mars.     

Visual terrain mapping for Mars exploration

One goal for future Mars missions is for a rover to be able to navigate autonomously to science targets not visible to the rover, but seen in orbital or descent images. This can be accomplished if accurate maps of the terrain are available for the rover to use in planning and localization. We describe techniques to generate such terrain maps using images with a variety of resolutions and scales, including surface images from the lander and rover, descent images captured by the lander as it approaches the planetary surface, and orbital images from current and future Mars orbiters. At the highest resolution, we process surface images captured by rovers and landers using bundle adjustment. At the next lower resolution (and larger scale), we use wide-baseline stereo vision to map terrain distant from a rover with surface images. Mapping the lander descent images using a structure-from-motion algorithm generates data at a hierarchy of resolutions. These provide a link between the high-resolution surface images and the low-resolution orbital images. Orbital images are mapped using similar techniques, although with the added complication that the images may be captured with a variety of sensors. Robust multi-modal matching techniques are applied to these images. The terrain maps are combined using a system for unifying multi-resolution models and integrating three-dimensional terrains. The result is a multi-resolution map that can be used to generate fixed-resolution maps at any desired scale.     

Efficient autonomous navigation for planetary rovers with limited resources

Rovers operating on Mars require more and more autonomous features to fulfill their challenging mission requirements. However, the inherent constraints of space systems render the implementation of complex algorithms an expensive and difficult task. In this paper, we propose an architecture for autonomous navigation. Efficient implementations of autonomous features are built on top of the ExoMars path following navigation approach to enhance the safety and traversing capabilities of the rover. These features allow the rover to detect and avoid hazards and perform significantly longer traverses planned by operators on the ground. The efficient navigation approach has been implemented and tested during field test campaigns on a planetary analogue terrain. The experiments evaluated the proposed architecture by autonomously completing several traverses of variable lengths while avoiding hazards. The approach relies only on the optical Localization Cameras stereo bench, a sensor that is found in all current rovers, and potentially allows for computationally inexpensive long‐range autonomous navigation in terrains of medium difficulty.     

Kinematics Modeling and Analyses of Articulated Rovers

This paper describes a general approach to the kinematics modeling and analyses of articulated rovers traversing uneven terrain. The model is derived for full 6-degree-of-freedom motion, enabling movements in the$x$,$y$, and$z$directions, as well as pitch, roll, and yaw rotations. Differential kinematics is derived for the individual wheel motions in contact with the terrain. The resulting equations of the individual wheel motions are then combined to form the composite equation for the rover motion. Three types of kinematics, i.e., navigation, actuation, and slip kinematics are identified, and the equations and application of each are discussed. The derivations are specialized to Rocky 7, a highly articulated prototype Mars rover, to illustrate the developed methods. Simulation results are provided for the motion of the Rocky 7 over several terrains, and various motion profiles are provided to explain the behavior of the rover.     

Planetary Rover Developments Supporting Mars Exploration, Sample Return and Future Human-Robotic Colonization

We overview our recent research on planetary mobility. Products of this effort include the Field Integrated Design & Operations rover (FIDO), Sample Return Rover (SRR), reconfigurable rover units that function as an All Terrain Explorer (ATE), and a multi-Robot Work Crew of closely cooperating rovers (RWC). FIDO rover is an advanced technology prototype; its design and field testing support NASA's development of long range, in situ Mars surface science missions. Complementing this, SRR implements autonomous visual recognition, navigation, rendezvous, and manipulation functions enabling small object pick-up, handling, and precision terminal docking to a Mars ascent vehicle for future Mars Sample Return. ATE implements on-board reconfiguration of rover geometry and control for adaptive response to adverse and changing terrain, e.g., traversal of steep, sandy slopes. RWC implements coordinated control of two rovers under closed loop kinematics and force constraints, e.g., transport of large payloads, as would occur in robotic colonies at future Mars outposts. RWC is based in a new extensible architecture for decentralized control of, and collective state estimation by multiple heterogeneous robotic platforms—CAMPOUT; we overview the key architectural features. We have conducted experiments with all these new rover system concepts over variable natural terrain. For each of the above developments, we summarize our approach, some of our key experimental results to date, and our future directions of planned development.     

Mars Science Laboratory Curiosity Rover Megaripple Crossings up to Sol 710 in Gale Crater

After landing in Gale Crater on August 6, 2012, the Mars Science Laboratory Curiosity rover traveled across regolith‐covered, rock‐strewn plains that transitioned into terrains that have been variably eroded, with valleys partially filled with windblown sands, and intervening plateaus capped by well‐cemented sandstones that have been fractured and shaped by wind into outcrops with numerous sharp rock surfaces. Wheel punctures and tears caused by sharp rocks while traversing the plateaus led to directing the rover to traverse in valleys where sands would cushion wheel loads. This required driving across a megaripple (windblown, sand‐sized deposit covered by coarser grains) that straddles a narrow gap and several extensive megaripple deposits that accumulated in low portions of valleys. Traverses across megaripple deposits led to mobility difficulties, with sinkage values up to approximately 30% of the 0.50 m wheel diameter, resultant high compaction resistances, and rover‐based slip up to 77%. Analysis of imaging and engineering data collected during traverses across megaripples for the first 710 sols (Mars days) of the mission, laboratory‐based single‐wheel soil experiments, full‐scale rover tests at the Dumont Dunes, Mojave Desert, California, and numerical simulations show that a combination of material properties and megaripple geometries explain the high wheel sinkage and slip events. Extensive megaripple deposits have subsequently been avoided and instead traverses have been implemented across terrains covered with regolith or thin windblown sand covers and megaripples separated by bedrock exposures.     

Learned Stochastic Mobility Prediction for Planning with Control Uncertainty on Unstructured Terrain

Motion planning for planetary rovers must consider control uncertainty in order to maintain the safety of the platform during navigation. Modeling such control uncertainty is difficult due to the complex interaction between the platform and its environment. In this paper, we propose a motion‐planning approach whereby the outcome of control actions is learned from experience and represented statistically using a Gaussian process regression model. This mobility prediction model is trained using sample executions of motion primitives on representative terrain, and it predicts the future outcome of control actions on similar terrain. Using Gaussian process regression allows us to exploit its inherent measure of prediction uncertainty in planning. We integrate mobility prediction into a Markov decision process framework and use dynamic programming to construct a control policy for navigation to a goal region in a terrain map built using an onboard depth sensor. We consider both rigid terrain, consisting of uneven ground, small rocks, and nontraversable rocks, and also deformable terrain. We introduce two methods for training the mobility prediction model from either proprioceptive or exteroceptive observations, and we report results from nearly 300 experimental trials using a planetary rover platform in a Mars‐analogue environment. Our results validate the approach and demonstrate the value of planning under uncertainty for safe and reliable navigation.     

Design and field testing of a rover with an actively articulated suspension system in a Mars analog terrain

This study presents the electromechanical design, the control approach, and the results of a field test campaign with the hybrid wheeled‐leg rover SherpaTT. The rover ranges in the 150 kg class and features an actively articulated suspension system comprising four legs with actively driven and steered wheels at each leg’s end. Five active degrees of freedom are present in each of the legs, resulting in 20 active degrees of freedom for the complete locomotion system. The control approach is based on force measurements at each wheel mounting point and roll–pitch measurements of the rover’s main body, allowing active adaption to sloping terrain, active shifting of the center of gravity within the rover’s support polygon, active roll–pitch influencing, and body‐ground clearance control. Exteroceptive sensors such as camera or laser range finder are not required for ground adaption. A purely reactive approach is used, rendering a planning algorithm for stability control or force distribution unnecessary and thus simplifying the control efforts. The control approach was tested within a 4‐week field deployment in the desert of Utah. The results presented in this paper substantiate the feasibility of the chosen approach: The main power requirement for locomotion is from the drive system, active adaption only plays a minor role in power consumption. Active force distribution between the wheels is successful in different footprints and terrain types and is not influenced by controlling the body’s roll–pitch angle in parallel to the force control. Slope‐climbing capabilities of the system were successfully tested in slopes of up to 28° inclination, covered with loose soil and duricrust. The main contribution of this study is the experimental validation of the actively articulated suspension of SherpaTT in conjunction with a reactive control approach. Consequently, hardware and software design as well as experimentation are part of this study.     

Seeker—Autonomous Long‐range Rover Navigation for Remote Exploration

Under the umbrella of the European Space Agency (ESA) StarTiger program, a rapid prototyping study called Seeker was initiated. A range of partners from space and nonspace sectors were brought together to develop a prototype Mars rover system capable of autonomously exploring several kilometers of highly representative Mars terrain over a three‐day period. This paper reports on our approach and the final field trials that took place in the Atacama Desert, Chile. Long‐range navigation and the associated remote rover field trials are a new departure for ESA, and this activity therefore represents a novel initiative in this area. The primary focus was to determine if current computer vision and artificial intelligence based software could enable such a capability on Mars, given the current limit of around 200 m per Martian day. The paper does not seek to introduce new theoretical techniques or compare various approaches, but it offers a unique perspective on their behavior in a highly representative environment. The final system autonomously navigated 5.05 km in highly representative terrain during one day. This work is part of a wider effort to achieve a step change in autonomous capability for future Mars/lunar exploration rover platforms.     

Long‐range rover localization by matching LIDAR scans to orbital elevation maps

Current rover localization techniques such as visual odometry have proven to be very effective on short‐ to medium‐length traverses (e.g., up to a few kilometers). This paper deals with the problem of long‐range rover localization (e.g., 10 km and up) by developing an algorithm named MOGA (Multi‐frame Odometry‐compensated Global Alignment). This algorithm is designed to globally localize a rover by matching features detected from a three‐dimensional (3D) orbital elevation map to features from rover‐based, 3D LIDAR scans. The accuracy and efficiency of MOGA are enhanced with visual odometry and inclinometer/sun‐sensor orientation measurements. The methodology was tested with real data, including 37 LIDAR scans of terrain from a Mars–Moon analog site on Devon Island, Nunavut. When a scan contained a sufficient number of good topographic features, localization produced position errors of no more than 100 m, of which most were less than 50 m and some even as low as a few meters. Results were compared to and shown to outperform VIPER, a competing global localization algorithm that was given the same initial conditions as MOGA. On a 10‐km traverse, MOGA's localization estimates were shown to significantly outperform visual odometry estimates. This paper shows how the developed algorithm can be used to accurately and autonomously localize a rover over long‐range traverses. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

基于选择交叉烟花算法的无人车路径规划

在三维地形环境下,基本烟花算法进行路径规划时易陷入局部最优解且存在收敛速度慢的问题,为此,提出选择交叉烟花算法。利用栅格法构建三维地形环境并设置威胁区域,使无人车选择合适的节点进行路径探索,结合燃耗代价、平滑代价和威胁代价构建适应度函数,以约束路径节点的生成位置,确保规划出的路径平滑且远离威胁区域。通过基本烟花算法的爆炸、变异、映射和选择操作进行路径搜索,同时加入针对路径节点的轮盘选择操作,使偏离原始路径较远的节点具有更高的爆炸概率,以约束路径的搜索方向,从而加快算法的搜索速度。在此基础上,引入选择交叉火花,通过对轮盘选择后节点间的路径片段进行交叉,以增强种群中烟花之间信息的交互性,提高搜索全局最优解的性能。仿真结果表明,相比基本烟花算法,该算法在简单和复杂地形环境下的适应度值平均提高6%,且运行时间平均缩短13.5%。在各类地形环境下,无人车通过该算法能有效规避威胁区域,并在较短时间内寻找到更加平滑且燃耗更低的路径。     

Theory and experiments in SmartNav rover navigation

This paper describes theoretical and experimental results using the SmartNav rule-free fuzzy rover navigation system. SmartNav divides the terrain perceived by the rover into a number of circular sectors, and evaluates each sector using goal and safety preference factors to differentiate between preferred and unpreferred terrain sectors. The goal-preference factor is used to make sector evaluation based on the sector orientation relative to the designated goal position. The safety-preference factors are used to make sector evaluations on the basis of the sector local and regional terrain hazards. Three methods are developed to blend the three sector evaluations in order to find the effective preference factor for each sector. Two sector selection methods are then described in which the sector preference factors are used to find the heading command for the rover. The rover speed command is also computed based on the goal distance and safety-preference factor of the chosen sector. The above navigation steps are continuously repeated throughout the rover motion. Experimental results are presented to demonstrate the navigational capabilities of SmartNav using a commercial Pioneer 2AT rover traversing a simulated Martian terrain at the JPL Mini Mars Yard.

---

     

Perception‐aware autonomous mast motion planning for planetary exploration rovers

Highly accurate real‐time localization is of fundamental importance for the safety and efficiency of planetary rovers exploring the surface of Mars. Mars rover operations rely on vision‐based systems to avoid hazards as well as plan safe routes. However, vision‐based systems operate on the assumption that sufficient visual texture is visible in the scene. This poses a challenge for vision‐based navigation on Mars where regions lacking visual texture are prevalent. To overcome this, we make use of the ability of the rover to actively steer the visual sensor to improve fault tolerance and maximize the perception performance. This paper answers the question of where and when to look by presenting a method for predicting the sensor trajectory that maximizes the localization performance of the rover. This is accomplished by an online assessment of possible trajectories using synthetic, future camera views created from previous observations of the scene. The proposed trajectories are quantified and chosen based on the expected localization performance. In this study, we validate the proposed method in field experiments at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) Mars Yard. Furthermore, multiple performance metrics are identified and evaluated for reducing the overall runtime of the algorithm. We show how actively steering the perception system increases the localization accuracy compared with traditional fixed‐sensor configurations.     

星球车松软星壤的轮腿式探测系统:Ⅱ-感知车轮

为增强星球车松软星壤的穿越通过能力,提出了轮壤交互接触信息的感知车轮设计。该车轮是一种星球车的前置轮腿式探测系统(WOLS)的关键部分,可实现动态轮壤交互的关键量测量(轮壤作用力/力矩、轮壤接触角和车轮沉陷量)。研究分析了轮壤力学的关键测量参量及其分组,完成了感知车轮的硬件设计和集成,提出了待测参数的在线测量模型和方法,通过标定校准和实车测试验证了该感知车轮的性能。     

基于微分平坦与MPC的智能车换道控制算法

为了提高智能车换道的安全性,提出了一种基于微分平坦理论与模型预测控制(MPC)算法相结合的智能车换道轨迹规划与跟踪算法。该算法利用约束求解得到基于sigmoid函数的优化路径;将其与多项式参数化时间函数作为平坦输出,利用微分平坦理论构造一个非线性性能指标函数并对其进行优化求解完成车速规划;从而实现对智能车辆路径-速度分解式的轨迹规划。利用动力学模型预测控制算法线上控制的优点,对智能车的车轮转向进行实时控制,使得车辆按照规划好的轨迹行驶完成换道。通过CarSim与MATLAB/Simulink的联合仿真,将提出的轨迹规划算法应用于车辆系统仿真软件中进行验证,结果表明该算法能够实现对智能车进行轨迹规划和跟踪控制,使其安全高效地换至目标车道。