A cooperative parallel metaheuristic for the capacitated vehicle routing problem

This paper introduces a cooperative parallel metaheuristic for the capacitated vehicle routing problem. The proposed metaheuristic consists of multiple parallel tabu search threads that cooperate by asynchronously exchanging best-found solutions through a common solution pool. The solutions sent to the pool are clustered according to their similarities. The search history information identified from the solution clusters is applied to guide the intensification or diversification of the tabu search threads. Computational experiments on two sets of large-scale benchmark instance sets from the literature demonstrate that the suggested metaheuristic is highly competitive, providing new best solutions to ten of those well-studied instances.     

A memetic algorithm for the travelling salesperson problem with hotel selection

In this paper, a metaheuristic solution procedure for the travelling salesperson problem with hotel selection (TSPHS) is presented. The metaheuristic consists of a memetic algorithm with an embedded tabu search, using a combination of well-known and problem-specific neighbourhoods. This solution procedure clearly outperforms the only other existing metaheuristic in the literature. For smaller instances, whose optimal solution is known, it is able to consistently find the optimal solution. For the other instances, it obtains several new best known solutions.     

A tabu search algorithm for the routing and capacity assignment problem in computer networks

A tabu search metaheuristic algorithm for a classical routing and capacity assignment (CFA) problem in computer networks is presented in this paper. Computational experiments across a variety of networks are reported. The results show that the proposed tabu search algorithm is both effective and efficient in finding good solutions of the CFA problem compared with the traditional Lagrangean relaxation and subgradient optimization technique. Extensive tests are made in order to choose the best values of the parameters for tabu search algorithm.     

Metaheuristic approaches to grouping problems in high-throughput cryopreservation operations for fish sperm

High-throughput cryopreservation operations of fish sperm is a technology being developed by researchers today. This paper first formulates a grouping problem in high-throughput cryopreservation operations of fish sperm and then develops a heuristic and four metaheuristic algorithms for its solution. The heuristic is modified from one originally proposed for the assembly line balancing problem. The four metaheuristic algorithms include simulated annealing (SA), tabu search (TS), ant colony optimization (ACO), and a hybrid differential evolution (hDE). For each metaheuristic algorithm, four different initialization methods were used. For both SA and TS, five different neighborhood solution generation methods were also studied. Real world data collected from a high-throughput cryopreservation operation was used to test the effectiveness of algorithms with different initialization and neighborhood solution generation methods. For comparison, a base line of grouping by processing order was also established. The results indicate that: (i) all algorithms performed better than the base line; (ii) using the result of the modified heuristic as the initial solution of metaheuristic algorithms lead to a better solution; the amount of improvement varied from algorithm to algorithm; (iii) among the five neighborhood solution generation operators, insertion operator was the best; (iv) among all algorithms tested, the hybrid differential evolution is the best, followed by tabu search in terms of average objective value.     

Fine-tuning a Tabu Search Algorithm with Statistical Tests

Tabu Search is a metaheuristic that has proven to be very effective for solving various types of combinatorial optimization problems. To achieve the best results with a tabu search algorithm, significant benefits can sometimes be gained by determining preferred values for certain search parameters such as tabu tenures, move selection probabilities, the timing and structure of elite solution recovery for intensification, etc. In this paper, we present and implement some new ideas for fine-tuning a tabu search algorithm using statistical tests. Although the focus of this work is to improve a particular tabu search algorithm developed for solving a telecommunications network design problem, the implications are quite general. The same ideas and procedures can easily be adapted and applied to other tabu search algorithms as well.     

Multistart Tabu Search and Diversification Strategies for the Quadratic Assignment Problem

The quadratic assignment problem (QAP) is a well-known combinatorial optimization problem with a wide variety of applications, prominently including the facility location problem. The acknowledged difficulty of the QAP has made it the focus of many metaheuristic solution approaches. In this paper, we show the benefit of utilizing strategic diversification within the tabu search (TS) framework for the QAP, by incorporating several diversification and multistart TS variants. Computational results for an extensive and challenging set of QAP benchmark test problems demonstrate the ability of our TS variants to improve on a classic TS approach that is one of the principal and most extensively used methods for the QAP. We also show that our new procedures are highly competitive with the best recently introduced methods from the literature, including more complex hybrid approaches that incorporate the classic TS method as a subroutine.     

A Memetic Approach to the Nurse Rostering Problem

Constructing timetables of work for personnel in healthcare institutions is known to be a highly constrained and difficult problem to solve. In this paper, we discuss a commercial system, together with the model it uses, for this rostering problem. We show that tabu search heuristics can be made effective, particularly for obtaining reasonably good solutions quickly for smaller rostering problems. We discuss the robustness issues, which arise in practice, for tabu search heuristics. This paper introduces a range of new memetic approaches for the problem, which use a steepest descent improvement heuristic within a genetic algorithm framework. We provide empirical evidence to demonstrate the best features of a memetic algorithm for the rostering problem, particularly the nature of an effective recombination operator, and show that these memetic approaches can handle initialisation parameters and a range of instances more robustly than tabu search algorithms, at the expense of longer solution times. Having presented tabu search and memetic approaches (both with benefits and drawbacks) we finally present an algorithm that is a hybrid of both approaches. This technique produces better solutions than either of the earlier approaches and it is relatively unaffected by initialisation and parameter changes, combining some of the best features of each approach to create a hybrid which is greater than the sum of its component algorithms.     

Metaheuristics for the waste collection vehicle routing problem with time windows,driver rest period and multiple disposal facilities

In this problem there is a set of waste disposal facilities, a set of customers at which waste is collected and an unlimited number of homogeneous vehicles based at a single depot. Empty vehicles leave the depot and collect waste from customers, emptying themselves at the waste disposal facilities as and when necessary. Vehicles return to the depot empty. We take into consideration time windows associated with customers, disposal facilities and the depot. We also have a driver rest period. The problem is solved heuristically. A neighbour set is defined for each customer as the set of customers that are close, but with compatible time windows. A procedure that attempts to fully utilise a vehicle is used to obtain an initial solution, with this initial solution being improved using an interchange procedure. We present two metaheuristic algorithms using tabu search and variable neighbourhood search that are based around the neighbour sets. We also present a metaheuristic based on variable neighbourhood tabu search, where the variable neighbourhood is searched via tabu search. Computational results are presented for publicly available waste collection problems involving up to 2092 customers and 19 waste disposal facilities, which indicate that our algorithms produce better quality solutions than previous work presented in the literature.     

A hybrid metaheuristic approach for the capacitated p-median problem

The capacitated p-median problem (CPMP) seeks to obtain the optimal location of p medians considering distances and capacities for the services to be given by each median. This paper presents an efficient hybrid metaheuristic algorithm by combining a proposed cutting-plane neighborhood structure and a tabu search metaheuristic for the CPMP. In the proposed neighborhood structure to move from the current solution to a neighbor solution, an open median is selected and closed. Then, a linear programming (LP) model is generated by relaxing binary constraints and adding new constraints. The generated LP solution is improved using cutting-plane inequalities. The solution of this strong LP is considered as a new neighbor solution. In order to select an open median to be closed, several strategies are proposed. The neighborhood structure is combined with a tabu search algorithm in the proposed approach. The parameters of the proposed hybrid algorithm are tuned using design of experiments approach. The proposed algorithm is tested on several sets of benchmark instances. The statistical analysis shows efficiency and effectiveness of the hybrid algorithm in comparison with the best approach found in the literature.     

A Global Repair Operator for Capacitated Arc Routing Problem

Capacitated arc routing problem (CARP) has attracted much attention during the last few years due to its wide applications in real life. Since CARP is NP-hard and exact methods are only applicable for small instances, heuristics and metaheuristic methods are widely adopted when solving CARP. This paper demonstrates one major disadvantage encountered by traditional search algorithms and proposes a novel operator named global repair operator (GRO) to address it. We further embed GRO in a recently proposed tabu search algorithm (TSA) and apply the resultant repair-based tabu search (RTS) algorithm to five well-known benchmark test sets. Empirical results suggest that RTS not only outperforms TSA in terms of quality of solutions but also converges to the solutions faster. Moreover, RTS is also competitive with a number of state-of-the-art approaches for CARP. The efficacy of GRO is thereby justified. More importantly, since GRO is not specifically designed for the referred TSA, it might be a potential tool for improving any existing method that adopts the same solution representation.     

Parallel machine total tardiness scheduling with a new hybrid metaheuristic approach

This work proposes a hybrid metaheuristic (HMH) approach which integrates several features from tabu search (TS), simulated annealing (SA) and variable neighbourhood search (VNS) in a new configurable scheduling algorithm. In particular, either a deterministic or a random candidate list strategy can be used to generate the neighbourhood of a solution, both a tabu list mechanism and the SA probabilistic rule can be adopted to accept solutions, and the dimension of the explored neighbourhood can be dynamically modified. The considered class of scheduling problems is characterized by a set of independent jobs to be executed on a set of parallel machines with non-zero ready times and sequence dependent setups. In particular, the NP-hard generalized parallel machine total tardiness problem (GPMTP) recently defined by Bilge et al. [A tabu search algorithm for parallel machine total tardiness problem. Computers & Operations Research 2004;31:397–414], is faced. Several alternative configurations of the HMH have been tested on the same benchmark set used by Bilge et al. The results obtained highlight the appropriateness of the proposed approach.     

A very fast TS/SA algorithm for the job shop scheduling problem

The job shop scheduling problem (JSP) is one of the most notoriously intractable NP-complete optimization problems. Over the last 10–15 years, tabu search (TS) has emerged as an effective algorithmic approach for the JSP. However, the quality of solutions found by tabu search approach depends on the initial solution. To overcome this problem and provide a robust and efficient methodology for the JSP, the heuristics search approach combining simulated annealing (SA) and TS strategy is developed. The main principle of this approach is that SA is used to find the elite solutions inside big valley (BV) so that TS can re-intensify search from the promising solutions. This hybrid algorithm is tested on the standard benchmark sets and compared with the other approaches. The computational results show that the proposed algorithm could obtain the high-quality solutions within reasonable computing times. For example, 17 new upper bounds among the unsolved problems are found in a short time.     

A graph coloring heuristic using partial solutions and a reactive tabu scheme

Most of the recent heuristics for the graph coloring problem start from an infeasible k-coloring (adjacent vertices may have the same color) and try to make the solution feasible through a sequence of color exchanges. In contrast, our approach (called FOO-PARTIALCOL), which is based on tabu search, considers feasible but partial solutions and tries to increase the size of the current partial solution. A solution consists of k disjoint stable sets (and, therefore, is a feasible, partial k-coloring) and a set of uncolored vertices. We introduce a reactive tabu tenure which substantially enhances the performance of both our heuristic as well as the classical tabu algorithm (called TABUCOL) proposed by Hertz and de Werra [Using tabu search techniques for graph coloring, Computing 1987;39:345–51]. We will report numerical results on different benchmark graphs and we will observe that FOO-PARTIALCOL, though very simple, outperforms TABUCOL on some instances, provides very competitive results on a set of benchmark graphs which are known to be difficult, and outperforms the best-known methods on the graph flat300_28_0. For this graph, FOO-PARTIALCOL finds an optimal coloring with 28 colors. The best coloring achieved to date uses 31 colors. Algorithms very close to TABUCOL are still used as intensification procedures in the best coloring methods, which are evolutionary heuristics. FOO-PARTIALCOL could then be a powerful alternative. In conclusion FOO-PARTIALCOL is one of the most efficient simple local search coloring methods yet available.     

A Neurogenetic approach for the resource-constrained project scheduling problem

A variety of metaheuristic approaches have emerged in recent years for solving the resource-constrained project scheduling problem (RCPSP), a well-known NP-hard problem in scheduling. In this paper, we propose a Neurogenetic approach which is a hybrid of genetic algorithms (GA) and neural-network (NN) approaches. In this hybrid approach the search process relies on GA iterations for global search and on NN iterations for local search. The GA and NN search iterations are interleaved in a manner that allows NN to pick the best solution thus far from the GA pool and perform an intensification search in the solution's local neighborhood. Similarly, good solutions obtained by NN search are included in the GA population for further search using the GA iterations. Although both GA and NN approaches, independently give good solutions, we found that the hybrid approach gives better solutions than either approach independently for the same number of shared iterations. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach empirically on the standard benchmark problems of size J30, J60, J90 and J120 from PSPLIB.     

A variable neighborhood search for minimizing single machine weighted earliness and tardiness with common due date

Although the concept of just-in-time (JIT) production systems has been proposed for over two decades, it is still important in real-world production systems. In this paper, we consider minimizing the total weighted earliness and tardiness with a restrictive common due date in a single machine environment, which has been proved as an NP-hard problem. Due to the complexity of the problem, metaheuristics, including simulated annealing, genetic algorithm, tabu search, among others, have been proposed for searching good solutions in reasonable computation times. In this paper, we propose a hybrid metaheuristic that uses tabu search within variable neighborhood search (VNS/TS). There are several distinctive features in the VNS/TS algorithm, including different ratio of the two neighborhoods, generating five points simultaneously in a neighborhood, implementation of the B/F local search, and combination of TS with VNS. By examining the 280 benchmark problem instances, the algorithm shows an excellent performance in not only the solution quality but also the computation time. The results obtained are better than those reported previously in the literature.     

Iterated local search algorithms for the Euclidean Steiner tree problem in n dimensions

We propose algorithmic frameworks based on the iterated local search (ILS) metaheuristic to obtain good‐quality solutions for the Euclidean Steiner tree problem (ESTP) in n dimensions. This problem consists in finding a tree with minimal total length that spans p points given in an n‐dimensional Euclidean space and, eventually, also some additional points whose insertion contributes to reduce the total length of the tree. These ILS approaches make use of both the tree enumeration structure, called topology‐describing vector, and the exact minimization step of a well‐known branch‐and‐bound method for the ESTP. Computational results are provided.     

Using tabu search with ranking candidate list to solve production planning problems with setups

This study considers production planning problems involving multiple products, multiple resources, multiple periods, setup times, and setup costs. It can be formulated as a mixed integer program (MIP). Solving a realistic MIP production planning problem is NP-hard; therefore, we use tabu search methods to solve such a difficult problem. Furthermore, we improve tabu search by a new candidate list strategy, which sorts the neighbor solutions using post-optimization information provided by the final tableau of the linear programming simplex algorithm. A neighbor solution with higher priority in the ranking sequence has a higher probability of being the best neighbor solution of a current solution. According to our experiments, the proposed candidate list strategy tabu search produces a good solution faster than the traditional simple tabu search. This study also suggests that if the evaluation of the entire neighborhood space in a tabu search algorithm takes too much computation and if an efficient and effective heuristic to rank the neighbor solutions can be developed, the speed of tabu search algorithm could be significantly increased by using the proposed candidate list strategy.     

A tabu search based hybrid evolutionary algorithm for the max-cut problem

This paper presents a tabu search based hybrid evolutionary algorithm (TSHEA) for solving the max-cut problem. The proposed algorithm integrates a distance-and-quality based solution combination operator and a tabu search procedure based on neighborhood combination of one-flip and constrained exchange moves. Comparisons with leading reference algorithms from the literature disclose that the proposed algorithm discovers new best solutions for 15 out of 91 instances, while matching the best known solutions on all but 4 instances. Analysis indicates that the neighborhood combination and the solution combination operator play key roles to the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm.     

A tabu search algorithm for parallel machine total tardiness problem

In this study, we consider the problem of scheduling a set of independent jobs with sequence dependent setups on a set of uniform parallel machines such that total tardiness is minimized. Jobs have non-identical due dates and arrival times. A tabu search (TS) approach is employed to attack this complex problem. In order to obtain a robust search mechanism, several key components of TS such as candidate list strategies, tabu classifications, tabu tenure and intensification/diversification strategies are investigated. Alternative approaches to each of these issues are developed and extensively tested on a set of problems obtained from the literature. The results obtained are considerably better than those reported previously and constitute the best solutions known for the benchmark problems as to date. Scope and purposeSeveral surveys on parallel machine scheduling with due date related objectives (Oper. Res. 38(1) (1990) 22; EJOR 38 (1989) 156; Oper. Res. 42 (1994) 1025) reveal that the NP-hard nature of the problem renders it a challenging area for many researchers who studied various versions. However, most of these studies make the assumption that jobs are available at the beginning of the scheduling period, which is an important deviation form reality. In this study, as well as distinct due dates and ready times, features such as sequence dependent setup times and different processing rates for machines are incorporated into the classical model. These enhancements approach the model to the actual practice at the expense of complicating the problem further. For this complex problem, we present a tabu search (TS) algorithm to minimize total tardiness and provide the best solutions known for a set of benchmark problems.     

Problem difficulty for tabu search in job-shop scheduling

Tabu search algorithms are among the most effective approaches for solving the job-shop scheduling problem (JSP). Yet, we have little understanding of why these algorithms work so well, and under what conditions. We develop a model of problem difficulty for tabu search in the JSP, borrowing from similar models developed for SAT and other NP-complete problems. We show that the mean distance between random local optima and the nearest optimal solution is highly correlated with the cost of locating optimal solutions to typical, random JSPs. Additionally, this model accounts for the cost of locating sub-optimal solutions, and provides an explanation for differences in the relative difficulty of square versus rectangular JSPs. We also identify two important limitations of our model. First, model accuracy is inversely correlated with problem difficulty, and is exceptionally poor for rare, very high-cost problem instances. Second, the model is significantly less accurate for structured, non-random JSPs. Our results are also likely to be useful in future research on difficulty models of local search in SAT, as local search cost in both SAT and the JSP is largely dictated by the same search space features. Similarly, our research represents the first attempt to quantitatively model the cost of tabu search for any NP-complete problem, and may possibly be leveraged in an effort to understand tabu search in problems other than job-shop scheduling.