Performance comparison of cocurrent and countercurrent flow solid oxide fuel cells

Solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) is a complicated system with heat and mass transfer as well as electrochemical reactions. The flowing configuration of fuel and oxidants in the fuel cell will greatly affect the performance of the fuel cell stack. Based on the developed mathematical model of direct internal reforming SOFC, this paper established a distributed parameters simulation model for cocurrent and countercurrent types of SOFC based on the volume-resistance characteristic modeling method. The steady-state distribution characteristics and dynamic performances were compared and were analyzed for cocurrent and countercurrent types of SOFCs. The results indicate that the cocurrent configuration of SOFC is more suitable with regard to performance and safety.     

Solid oxide fuel cell: Decade of progress,future perspectives and challenges

In an increasing demand of renewable energy resources, fuel cell represents the highly efficient, clean and sustainable energy conversion source. Broadly speaking, fuel cell can be divided into six different categories according to the types of electrolyte and fuels used. Each type of fuel cells has their own advantages and disadvantages. Among them, solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) gains significant attentions due to their high efficiency, cost-effectiveness and the possibility to utilize variety of fuels other than hydrogen such as hydrocarbons, coal gas etc. As name implies, SOFC uses solid electrolyte for their operation. Indeed, in medium and large power requirement sectors, SOFC are highly suitable. In the present review article, recent advances and future perspectives of SOFC have been discussed via reviewing the literature over last five years. Most of the available review articles discussed the literature in terms of specific SOFC component such as anode, cathode, electrolytes and so on. In contrast, herein the literatures have been reviewed in the context of two types of SOFC stack designs i.e. planar and tubular that have been immensely used to fabricate efficient SOFC devices. Furthermore, fundamental of SOFC operation and its typical I–V characteristics and SOFC designs are also discussed in detail. Furthermore, preparation techniques for planar and tubular SOFC are briefly described. Finally, some of the recent trends in SOFC technology along with challenges and future perspectives are presented in this review article.     

Experimental simulation on the integration of solid oxide fuel cell and micro-turbine generation system

Solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) is characterized in high performance and high temperature exhaust, and it has potential to reach 70% efficiency if combined with gas turbine engine (GT). Because the SOFC is in developing stage, it is too expensive to obtain. This paper proposes a feasibility study by using a burner (Comb A) to simulate the high temperature exhaust gas of SOFC. The second burner (Comb B) is connected downstream of Comb A, and preheated hydrogen is injected to simulate the condition of sequential burner (SeqB). A turbocharger and a water injection system are also integrated in order to simulate the situation of a real SOFC/GT hybrid system. The water injection system is used to simulate the water mist addition at external reformer.     

Performance analysis of hybrid solid oxide fuel cell and gas turbine cycle (part I): Effects of fuel composition on output power

In this paper, the model of hybrid solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) and gas turbine (GT) cycle is applied to investigate the effects of the inlet fuel type and composition on the performance of the hybrid SOFC–GT cycle. The sensitivity analyses of the impacts of the concentration of the different components, namely, methane, hydrogen, carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, and nitrogen, in the inlet fuel on the performance of the hybrid SOFC–GT cycle are performed. The simulation results are presented with respect to a reference case, when the system is fueled by pure methane. Then, the performance of the hybrid SOFC–GT system when methane is partially replaced by each component within a corresponding range of concentration with an increment of 5% at each step is investigated. The results point out that the output powers of the SOFC, GT, and cycle as a whole decrease sharply when methane is replaced with other species in majority of the cases.     

A direct-flame solid oxide fuel cell (DFFC) operated on methane,propane, and butane

This paper presents an experimental study of a direct-flame type solid oxide fuel cell (DFFC). The operation principle of this system is based on the combination of a combustion flame with a solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) in a simple, no-chamber setup. The flame front serves as fuel reformer located a few millimeters from the anode surface while at the same time providing the heat required for SOFC operation. Experiments were performed using 13-mm-diameter planar SOFCs with Ni-based anode, samaria-doped ceria electrolyte and cobaltite cathode. At the anode, a 45-mm-diameter flat-flame burner provided radially homogeneous methane/air, propane/air, and butane/air rich premixed flames. The cell performance reaches power densities of up to 120 mW cm⁻², varying systematically with flame conditions. It shows a strong dependence on cell temperature. From thermodynamic calculations, both H₂ and CO were identified as species that are available as fuel for the SOFC. The results demonstrate the potential of this system for fuel-flexible power generation using a simple setup.     

Fault-tolerant control for steam fluctuation in SOFC system with reforming units

Faults of solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) systems can affect the characteristics of the stack and inhibit SOFC system commercialization. It has been found that the temperature fluctuation of the burner caused by fluctuation of steam flow rate would greatly affect the temperature of SOFC system and even exceed the safe operation range. Firstly, this paper introduces a mathematical model for the process of steam and natural gas reforming in a real SOFC system. Secondly, the cause of the burner temperature fluctuation is analyzed, and the model to simulate this faulty situation is established. Then, the Bayesian regularization neural network is used for fault diagnosis and good test results are obtained. Finally, fuzzy fault-tolerant control strategy is designed for the thermal safety problem of SOFC system. The simulation results validate the effectiveness of the proposed fault-tolerant control strategy.     

Control of a solid oxide fuel cell stack based on unmodeled dynamic compensations

To guarantee solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) safe operation, plenty control strategies have been developed to control stack temperature and voltage within a reasonable range. However, these control approaches ignore unmodeled dynamics of the SOFC system, which may lead to unsatisfactory control results, sometimes even make the system unstable. To overcome this challenge, a unique control strategy which considers unmodeled dynamic compensations of the SOFC system is proposed in this paper. A model of the SOFC system is firstly built, which includes a known linear model and an unmodeled nonlinear dynamic estimation. A nonlinear controller based on the unmodeled dynamic compensation is then developed to force the SOFC to track desired stack temperature and voltage. To evaluate the control performance, the proposed control method is compared with a traditional sliding mode controller. The simulation results show if the unmodeled dynamics have a small effect on the SOFC, both the sliding mode controller and the proposed controller can achieve a precise tracking. If the unmodeled dynamics have a great impact on the SOFC, the temperature and voltage can be well controlled with the proposed control strategy. However, in the sliding mode controller, the temperature and voltage trajectories deviate largely from the reference values.     

Optimization of a solid oxide fuel cell and micro gas turbine hybrid system

For a solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) and micro gas turbine (MGT) hybrid system, optimal control of load changes requires optimal dynamic scheduling of set points for the system's controllers. Thus, this paper proposes an improved iterative particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm to optimize the operating parameters under various loads. This method combines the iteration method and the PSO algorithm together, which can execute the discrete PSO iteratively until the control profile would converge to an optimal one. In MATLAB environment, the simulation results show that the SOFC/MGT hybrid model with the optimized parameters can effectively track the output power with high efficiency. Hence, the improved iterative PSO algorithm can be helpful for system analysis, optimization design, and real‐time control of the SOFC/MGT hybrid system. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Parameter identification for solid oxide fuel cells using cooperative barebone particle swarm optimization with hybrid learning

Solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) has been widely recognized as one of the most promising fuel cells. The SOFC performance is highly influenced by several parameters associated with the internal multi-physicochemical processes. In this work, the optimal modeling strategy is designed to determine the parameters of SOFC using a simple and efficient barebone particle swarm optimization (BPSO) algorithm. The cooperative coevolution strategy is applied to divide the output voltage function into four subfunctions based on the interdependence among variables. To the nonlinear characteristic of SOFC model, a hybrid learning strategy is proposed for BPSO to ensure a good balance between exploration and exploitation. The experimental results illustrate the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm. The comparisons also indicate that cooperative coevolution strategy and hybrid learning improve the performance of original PSO algorithm, offering better approximation effect and stronger robustness.     

Application of adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system techniques and artificial neural networks to predict solid oxide fuel cell performance in residential microgeneration installation

This study applies adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system (ANFIS) techniques and artificial neural network (ANN) to predict solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) performance while supplying both heat and power to a residence. A microgeneration 5 kW_el SOFC system was installed at the Canadian Centre for Housing Technology (CCHT), integrated with existing mechanical systems and connected in parallel to the grid. SOFC performance data were collected during the winter heating season and used for training of both ANN and ANFIS models. The ANN model was built on back propagation algorithm as for ANFIS model a combination of least squares method and back propagation gradient decent method were developed and applied. Both models were trained with experimental data and used to predict selective SOFC performance parameters such as fuel cell stack current, stack voltage, etc.     

Simulation of a SOFC/Battery powered vehicle

Solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) have received attention in the transport sector for use as auxiliary power units or range extenders, due to the high electrical efficiency and fuelling options using existing fuel infra structure. The present work proposes an SOFC/battery powered vehicle using compressed natural gas (CNG), liquefied natural gas (LNG) or liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) as fuels. A model was developed integrating an SOFC into a modified Nissan Leaf Acenta electrical vehicle and considering standardized driving cycles. A 30 L fuel tank and 12 kW SOFC module was simulated, including a partial oxidation fuel reformer. The results show a significant increase of the driving range when combining the battery vehicle with an SOFC. Ranges of 264 km, 705 km and 823 km using respectively CNG, LNG and LPG compared to 170 km performed by the original vehicle were calculated. Furthermore, a thorough sensitivity analysis was carried out.     

Economic feasibility of solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) for power generation in Iran

Supply utilities needed in site with the lowest cost and emission and highest efficiency are considered one of the main concerns of the process industry’s owners that requires doing more research in this area. In this research, during a case study, first comprehensive site of producing utility is optimized, and then the energy and environmental analysis of fuel cell system is taken place. Then fuel cell integration with utility site during two scenarios of entire supply of steam generated by HRSG of gas turbine and entire supply of gas turbine generated power was evaluated. According to the evaluation done, if the target is the entire supply of steam generated by HRSG of gas turbine, selecting solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) system is economically and environmentally more affordable. So if the target is preheating, selecting the system is based on entire supply of steam generated by the boilers, and the number of eight SOFC systems will be required by which a power about 22 MW can be produced.     

Effects of operating and design parameters on the performance of a solid oxide fuel cell–gas turbine system

We present a steady‐state thermodynamic model of a hybrid solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC)–gas turbine (GT) cycle developed using a commercial process simulation software, AspenPlus?. The hybrid cycle model incorporates a zero‐dimensional macro‐level SOFC model. A parametric study was carried out using the developed model to study the effects of system pressure, SOFC operating temperature, turbine inlet temperature, steam‐to‐carbon ratio, SOFC fuel utilization factor, and GT isentropic efficiency on the specific work output and efficiency of a generic hybrid cycle with and without anode recirculation. The results show that system pressure and SOFC operating temperature increase the cycle efficiency regardless of the presence of anode recirculation. On the other hand, the specific work decreases with operating temperature. Overall, the model can successfully capture the complex performance trends observed in hybrid cycles. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

A study of solid oxide fuel cell stack failure by inducing abnormal behavior in a single cell test

It is well known that cell imbalance can lead to failure of batteries. Prior theoretical modeling has shown that similar failure can occur in solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) stacks due to cell imbalance. Central to failure model for SOFC stacks is the abnormal operation of a cell with cell voltage becoming negative. For investigation of SOFC stack failure by simulating abnormal behavior in a single cell test, thin yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ) electrolyte, anode-supported cells were tested at 800 °C with hydrogen as fuel and air as oxidant with and without an applied DC bias. When under a DC bias with cell operating under a negative voltage, rapid degradation occurred characterized by increased cell resistance. Visual and microscopic examination revealed that delamination occurred along the electrolyte/anode interface. The present results show that anode-supported SOFC stacks with YSZ electrolyte are prone to catastrophic failure due to internal pressure buildup, provided cell imbalance occurs. The present results also suggest that the greater the number of cells in an SOFC stack, the greater is the propensity to catastrophic failure.     

Development of 1 kW SOFC power package for dual-fuel operation

A compact SOFC power generation system was developed by integrating a 1 kW SOFC stack and balance-of-plant. The system was designed for dual-fuel operation using both natural gas (NG) and liquefied petroleum gas (LPG). An adiabatic pre-reformer was employed in a fuel processing system to convert C₂₊ hydrocarbons in the fuel into CH₄-rich gas which was further processed in a main reformer to produce H₂-rich gas for the SOFC stack. The SOFC system was operated for 350 h under thermally self-sustaining condition, and on-load fuel switching from NG to LPG was carried out during the operation. The system performance was not significantly affected by NG/LPG composition ratios and the performance was stable during continuous operation in NG or LPG.     

Two-dimensional modeling for physical processes in direct flame fuel cells

Commercial direct flame fuel cells (DFFC) need larger cell surface area for higher power output. In such cases, multi-dimensional effects play significant roles on cell performances. In this work, a two-dimensional numerical model is developed to illustrate physical behaviors associated with the multi-dimensional effects in DFFCs. It is revealed that DFFCs suffer from the negative consequences of non-uniform distributions of temperature, species and voltage in radial direction. Non-uniform distributions of temperature and species results in the decrease of current density at edge regions of DFFCs, owing to lower ionic conductivities and fuel species concentration. And the non-uniform voltage distribution in radial direction causes the decreases of current density at center regions of DFFCs due to the lower over-potential there. Therefore, current density distributions in electrolytes are likely to be M-shaped. The multi-dimensional effects become progressively important with increasing the size of solid oxide fuel cells. Comparing with the DFFC with a SOFC with small cell radius (6.5 mm), a DFFC with a SOFC with large cell radius (33.75 mm) has 25–30% lower maximum power density. We also reveal that cross-over electronic currents in samaria-doped-ceria electrolytes and fuel species starvation due to the secondary oxidation are dominant factors on the cell performance loss at high cell temperatures (∼1000 K).     

Part-load,startup, and shutdown strategies of a solid oxide fuel cell-gas turbine hybrid system

Current work on the performance of a solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) and gas turbine hybrid system is presented. Each component model developed and applied is mathematically defined. The electrochemical performance of single SOFC with different fuels is tested. Experimental results are used to validate the SOFC mathematical model. Based on the simulation model, a safe operation regime of the hybrid system is accurately plotted first. Three different part-load strategies are introduced and used to analyze the part-load performance of the hybrid system using the safe regime. Another major objective of this paper is to introduce a suitable startup and shutdown strategy for the hybrid system. The sequences for the startup and shutdown are proposed in detail, and the system responses are acquired with the simulation model. Hydrogen is used instead of methane during the startup and shutdown process. Thus, the supply of externally generated steam is not needed for the reforming reaction. The gas turbine is driven by complementary fuel and supplies compressed air to heat up or cool down the SOFC stack operating temperature. The dynamic simulation results show that smooth cooling and heating of the cell stack can be accomplished without external electrical power.     

External temperature field test and leakage fault diagnosis for SOFC stacks

The uniformity of Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (SOFC) stacks largely affects the stability and performance of the SOFC power generation system with multiple stacks. However, the health conditions of the stacks are usually assessed by the long-time electrochemical performance test, and some small faults are not able to be quickly identified when the I–V performances have small differences. In this paper, a non-contact temperature sensor array constructed by thermocouples is proposed for NDE (non-destructive evaluation) application in SOFC stacks. The temperature sensor array is fixed near the outer surfaces of the 1 kW-class stack to measure the external temperature field of the stack. Based on the experimental results, it is found that the proposed method is feasible for the examination of the external temperature field of stacks under different operation conditions, which helps to screening the stacks before assembling to the system. At the same time, a real-time online monitoring of fuel leakage is performed using the temperature sensor array, and stacks with unusual temperature distribution due to the leakages can be quickly recognized by comparing with the healthy stack.     

Efficiency gain of solid oxide fuel cell systems by using anode offgas recycle - Results for a small scale propane driven unit

The transfer of high electrical efficiencies of solid oxide fuel cells (SOFC) into praxis requires appropriate system concepts. One option is the anode-offgas recycling (AOGR) approach, which is based on the integration of waste heat using the principle of a chemical heat pump.The AOGR concept allows a combined steam- and dry-reforming of hydrocarbon fuel using the fuel cell products steam and carbon dioxide. SOFC fuel gas of higher quantity and quality results. In combination with internal reuse of waste heat the system efficiency increases compared to the usual path of partial oxidation (POX).The demonstration of the AOGR concept with a 300 Wel-SOFC stack running on propane required: a combined reformer/burner-reactor operating in POX (start-up) and AOGR modus; a hotgas-injector for anode-offgas recycling to the reformer; a dynamic process model; a multi-variable process controller; full system operation for experimental proof of the efficiency gain.Experimental results proof an efficiency gain of 18 percentage points (η·POX = 23%, η·AOGR = 41%) under idealized lab conditions. Nevertheless, further improvements of injector performance, stack fuel utilization and additional reduction of reformer reformer O/C ratio and system pressure drop are required to bring this approach into self-sustaining operation.     

Analysis of total energy system based on solid oxide fuel cell for combined cooling and power applications

A total energy system (TES) incorporating a solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) and an exhaust gas driven absorption chiller (AC) is presented to provide power, cooling and/or heating simultaneously. The purpose for using the absorption chiller is to recover the exhaust heat from the SOFC exhaust gas for enhancing the energy utilization efficiency of the TES. A steady-state mathematical model is developed to simulate the effects of different operating conditions of SOFC, such as the fuel utilization factor and average current density, on the performance of the TES by using the MATLAB softpackage. Parametric analysis shows that both electrical efficiency and total efficiency of the TES have maximum values with variation of the fuel utilization factor; while the cooling efficiency increases, the electrical efficiency and total efficiency decrease with increase in the current density of SOFC. The simulated results could provide useful knowledge for the design and optimization of the proposed total energy system.