Influence of polymer enhancement on water uptake,retention and barrier performance of geosynthetic clay liners

This paper explores the influence of polymer enhancement on water uptake and retention by geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs) across a wide suction range (up to 10⁶ kPa), including the low suction regime (0.1–10 kPa) typically omitted in past studies. The suction measurement methods used enabled elucidation of water uptake and retention behaviour through the framework of GCL pore structures and their corresponding suction regimes. Polymer enhanced GCLs (PE-GCLs) have high maximum water uptake, and both the water entry and air expulsion values tend to be high. Due to high swelling, the onset of geotextile confinement for PE-GCLs was observed at high suctions. The impact of polymer becomes more apparent when the bentonite achieves a pseudo-two-layer interlayer hydration state at a suction of about 40 MPa (RH = 75%). The hydration mechanism for the polymer fraction in bentonite is unique to the specific polymer type, polymer dosage, and manufacturing process. The water retention behaviour at the low suction range is caused by the in-filling of geotextile pores, bentonite swelling and extrusion, and polymer water adsorption. Insights from this study can form the basis for developing a more suitable bimodal generalised model for fitting the water retention curves of GCLs.     

A novel transient gravimetric monitoring technique implemented to GCL osmotic suction control

A modified osmotic suction control technique for monitoring apparent transient weight changes was successfully adapted to the wetting and drying paths of geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs). Reasonable control was possible, enabling suction equilibrium to be achieved without disruption to the test. The results provide unique insight into the time-dependent changes in water retention properties and the semi-permeable membrane behaviour of the bentonite component in GCLs. The stages of suction equilibrium, related to the tri-modal pore structure of GCLs and the point of capillary break, could also be monitored. While the osmotic method has been traditionally used to control matric suction (up to 10 MPa) in soils, the overall results presented in this paper indicate that its application for total suction control in GCLs is largely due to the membrane behaviour of their bentonite component. Furthermore, because of capillary break between the GCL and the osmotic solution at the water entry (or residual) suction value of a GCL, an upper limit of 2.8 MPa suction is recommended for the application of the osmotic method to measure the water retention properties of GCLs.     

Effect of water salinity on the water retention curve of geosynthetic clay liners

The effect of water salinity on the water retention curve of geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs), under constant volume condition is examined. The results indicate that at a constant gravimetric moisture content the total suction increases as the salinity of the wetting liquid increases. Furthermore, the difference in total suction between the GCL hydrated by saline water and distilled water is greater than the difference in the osmotic potential of the wetting water. This behaviour is possibly caused by the matric suction being affected by the expected chemically induced pore size change of the bentonite component of the GCL.     

Insufficient initial hydration of GCLs from some subgrades: Factors and causes

Water retention and hydration tests are reported for three needle punched geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs). GCLs hydration and their maximum hydration capacity were assessed against subgrade soils prepared at different initial gravimetric water contents. The subgrade soil mineralogy and particle size distribution, as well as the carrier geotextiles used in GCLs, are shown to have a significant impact on the GCLs hydration behaviour. This work highlights the need to consider the unsaturated properties of both the GCLs and the subgrade soil when assessing the hydration of the GCLs. At gravimetric water contents above the GCL water entry value (≈30%), some forms of GCL configuration may be better than others with respect to ability to hydrate from a given soil. However, the partial hydration of GCL is mostly controlled by the bentonite microstructure for gravimetric water contents below the water entry value of the GCLs.     

Effect of stress on water retention of needlepunched geosynthetic clay liners

Geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs) are placed at the bottom of waste disposal facilities where they hydrate from the subsoil and eventually from a hydraulic head on geomembranes (GMs) defects. Predicting hydration behavior of GCLs requires knowledge of the water-retention properties of the GCL along wetting paths. Given that GCLs could be subjected to different ranges of vertical stresses that are induced by the weight of the supported waste, the confining stress could affect water-retention properties of GCLs and should be investigated. To do so, a laboratory methodology to establish the water-retention curves (WRCs) of needlepunched GCLs under stress was undertaken. Various constant vertical stresses corresponding to different weights of the supported waste were applied to GCL specimens placed in controlled-suction oedometers. Suction values were selected so as to mimic a wetting path from the initial dry state to zero suction. Suction was controlled by using controlled suction techniques with controlled humidity imposed by a saturated saline solutions and using the osmotic technique with polyethylene glycol (PEG) solutions. Measurements were undertaken on oedometer systems as to apply confining stresses and have been complemented by standard saturated oedometer swelling tests. The data obtained confirm that increasing the stress on to the GCL results in less, albeit faster, water uptake, which could emphasize on recommendations about rapidly covering GCLs after they are placed at the bottom of a waste disposal facilities. Finally, the potential validity of the state-surface concept, which was developed in unsaturated soil mechanics, is discussed using van Guenuchten's and Fredlund and Xing's equations for water retention curves.     

Water retention curves of a geosynthetic clay liner under non-uniform temperature-stress paths

This paper presents a novel suction-controlled chamber that permits the determination of the full water retention curves of geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs) under non-uniform temperature-stress paths. It investigates field conditions encountered in brine ponds (low confining stress settings) and heap leach pads (high confining stress settings) during construction and operation stages. Consequently, the analysis of the moisture dynamics in a GCL was defined under the wetting path (construction) and drying path (operation). High vertical stresses were found to facilitate a more rapid water uptake as capillarity is established faster than at low, confined stresses. In general, the drying curves increase the water desorption over the suction range investigated due to the low water viscosity caused by high temperatures. The wetting of the GCL at 20 °C and drying at 70 °C under either low, confined stress (2 kPa) or high confining stress (130 kPa) shows a reduction in the volumetric water contents. Furthermore, on the drying path, the coupled effect of elevated temperature and high confining stress accelerates water desorption leading possibly to potential desiccation.     

Water exchange across a subgrade-GCL interface as impacted by polymers and environmental conditions

This paper examines the hydration behaviour of polymer enhanced geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs) under both isothermal conditions and diurnal cyclical temperatures as recorded at a Melbourne landfill site. The diurnal temperature cycles introduced thermal gradients, which induced water movement downwards into the subgrade. It was found that the bulk of the thermal and hydraulic effects occurred within the upper 50 mm of the subgrade layer. Compared to isothermal conditions, diurnal temperature cycling's main effect was to suppress GCL hydration. Thermal gradients induced capillary breaks, and GCL hydration was thus limited to vapour phase hydration from the subgrade, which restricted the gravimetric water content of the GCLs to <30%. The hydration process at the interface was observed to gradually return to isothermal condition hydration levels once the temperature cycle conditions were removed. While the polymer's presence ensures the adsorption of more water, it also renders GCLs more sensitive to the effects of temperature. This study provides insights on the hydration behaviour of uncovered GCLs in field applications and the impact that diurnal temperature cycles can have on GCL hydration in a Mediterranean type climate.     

Geosynthetic clay liners: Perceptions and misconceptions

The behaviour of geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs) as part of a physical-environmental system is examined. Consideration is given to: (a) both the physical and hydraulic interactions with the materials, and the chemical interactions with the fluids, above and below the liner, (b) time-dependent changes in the materials, (c) heat generated from the material to be contained, as well as (d) the climatic conditions both during construction and during service. This paper explores some common perceptions about GCL behaviour and then examines the misconceptions that can arise and their implications. It demonstrates how what may first appear obvious is not always as one expects and that more is not always better. It discusses: (i) the pore structure of a GCL, (ii) the dependency of the water retention curve of the GCL on its structure, bentonite particle sizes and applied stress, (iii) the effect of the subgrade pore water chemistry, (iv) the mineralogy of the subgrade, and (v) thermal effects. The desirability of a GCL being reasonably well-hydrated before being permeated is examined. The critical size of needle-punch bundles at which preferential flow can increase hydraulic conductivity by orders of magnitude is illustrated. The dependency of self-healing of holes on the interaction between GCL and subgrade is discussed. Finally, the transmissivity of the geomembrane/GCL interface is shown to be a function of GCL and geomembrane characteristics and to be poorly correlated with GCL hydraulic conductivity.     

Laboratory investigation of GCL hydration from Lateritic subsoils

A laboratory investigation on the hydration behavior of GCLs from lateritic soils was conducted under isothermal and thermal conditions (tropical climate), varying subsoil moisture contents, GCLs bentonite particle size and mineralogy. GCL hydration levels from lateritic subsoils under isothermal conditions (55%) were similar to literature findings. A slight decrease in water content of some GCLs after long periods of contact with the lateritic soils indicates that equilibrium can demand long time in these soils. GCL with granular bentonites were less efficient to hydrate from lateritic subsoils. GCLs with activated-calcium bentonites maintained hydration levels in long-term. Nonwoven geotextile facing down favored capillary effects. Thermal cycles significantly influenced GCLs hydration from subsoils. Capillary connections developed during hydration under isothermal conditions due to suction gradient reductions. Post-hydration tests under isothermal conditions showed more alterations in GCLs swelling and cation exchange properties than thermal cycles test. An increase in the saturated hydraulic conductivity of GCLs was observed in both lateritic soils, mainly for isothermal condition, although continued attending hydraulic conductivity requirements for barrier applications.     

Interface shear strength between geosynthetic clay liner and covering soil on the embankment of an irrigation pond and stability evaluation of its widened sections

Geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs) are typically used for widening sections of an embankment. They are also used as low permeability liners to minimize water leakage from reservoirs such as irrigation ponds. However, few investigations have been carried out on the specific properties of GCLs, such as granulated bentonite sandwiched between geotextiles, their internal shear strength, and the shear strength at the interface between a GCL and an embankment body. In this study, a series of direct box shear tests were performed to determine the shear strength properties of bentonite and compacted soils as well as at the interface between a GCL and bentonite or compacted soil. In addition, a series of field-loading tests were conducted to investigate the failure behaviour of an embankment body containing a GCL when changes in the water content of the bentonite of the GCL in a real embankment occur. Furthermore, the stability of widened embankment bodies that incorporated GCLs were evaluated. The main conclusions of this study are as follows: (1) The shear strength of the interface between the covering soil and geotextiles varied according to the soil type, geotextile type, and the submergence period, (2) the maximum safety factor was observed at the interface between decomposed granite soil and the geotextiles, while the minimum safety factor was observed at the interface between the bentonite and the geotextiles, and (3) the influence of GCLs on the instability of a widened embankment was extremely small.     

The effects of technological voids on the hydro-mechanical behaviour of compacted bentonite–sand mixture

Compacted bentonite-based materials are often used as buffer materials in radioactive waste disposal. A good understanding of their hydro-mechanical behaviour is essential to ensure disposal safety. In this study, a mixture of MX80 bentonite and sand was characterised in the laboratory in terms of water retention property, swelling pressure, compressibility and hydraulic conductivity. The effects of the technological voids or the voids inside the soil were investigated. The technological voids are referred to as the macro-pores related to different interfaces involving the buffer material, whereas the voids inside the soil are referred to as common macro-pores within the compacted bentonite/sand mixture. The results obtained show that at high suction, the amount of water absorbed in the soil depends solely on suction, whereas at low suction it depends on both suction and the bentonite void ratio. There is a unique relationship between the swelling pressure and the bentonite void ratio, regardless of the sample nature (homogeneous or not) and the sand fraction. However, at the same bentonite void ratio, a higher hydraulic conductivity was obtained on the samples with technological voids. The effect of sand fraction was evidenced in the mechanical yield behaviour: at the same bentonite void ratio, the bentonite–sand mixture yielded at a higher pre-consolidation stress.     

Investigating factors influencing polymer elution and the mechanism controlling the chemical compatibility of GCLs containing linear polymers

A study was conducted to investigate (1) physicochemical factors that influence polymer elution from GCLs containing a blend of bentonite and linear (water-soluble) polymer (LPB GCLs) and (2) the mechanism that controls the chemical compatibility of LPB GCLs when polymer elutes. A series of hydraulic conductivity (k), free swell and viscosity tests were performed on a commercial LPB GCL using DI water, varying concentrations of NaCl and CaCl?. Comparable tests were also performed on a conventional bentonite (CB) GCL containing the same untreated bentonite and the same physical properties as the LPB GCL. The LPB GCL showed improved swelling and hydraulic performance compared to the CB GCL when permeated with salt solutions. Total organic carbon analysis of the effluents showed that polymer eluted from the LPB GCL regardless of the permeant solution. However, the rate at which polymer eluted increased as the concentration and valence of the dominant cation increased. The rate at which polymer eluted also increased with hydraulic gradient. The mass of polymer retained inside the GCL matrix did not correlate with the k of the LPB GCL. Free swell tests coupled with chemical analysis suggest that, the improved chemical compatibility of the LPB GCL was due to the ability of the polymer to scavenge cations from the solution which allows the bentonite to undergo adequate swelling during the initial hydration period. Analogous to water-prehydrated CB GCLs, the dispersed structure of the bentonite fabric and increased adsorbed water molecules attained during initial swelling controls the k of the LPB GCL when polymer elutes.     

Water retention of geosynthetics clay liners: Dependence on void ratio and temperature

The dependence of the geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs) soil-water characteristic curve (SWCC) on temperature and overburden stress are characterised experimentally. It is shown that changes in void ratio and temperature alter the relationship between suction and moisture content and new forms of existing SWCC equations are developed. To cover a wide suction range, the SWCCs are measured using axis-translation and dew point methods. Based on the available experimental data, both proposed SWCCs are shown to perform well in predicting the effects of void ratio on SWCC along the drying path when compared to the experimental results. It is found that the air-entry value increases as the net vertical stress increases for the experiments under the same temperature. In addition, elevation of temperature reduces retention capacity of the GCL.     

Current status of the Cincinnati GCL test plots

This paper describes the design, layout, construction and current status on the performance of fourteen full scale test plots targeted at assessing the internal shear strength of GCLs in landfill cover applications. Five different commercially available GCLs from four manufacturers were used in the study. Each test plot is two geosynthetic clay line roll widths wide, with lengths of 29m (95 ft) on the 3(H)-to-1(V) (horizontal-to-vertical) slopes and 20m (67 ft) on the 2(H)-to-1(V) (horizontal-to-vertical) slopes. The plots are being monitored with numerous deformation ‘telltales’ as well as subgrade and GCL moisture gages.

Two slides occurred shortly after construction. Both involved the upper surfaces of the GCLs against the overlying textured geomembranes. The slides were clearly the result of bentonite lubricated interfaces and (although of interest) did not relate to the internal shear strength focus and goals of the project.

Upon inducing internal shear stress in the GCLs by cutting all of the overlying geosynthetics, the deformations have been small except for one plot. This plot involved a unreinforced bentonite GCL, sandwiched between two geomembranes. It was sampled and found to have a large region of unexpected and excessively high moisture content. Subsequently, the test plot slid, the interface being the upper geomembrane against the bentonite of the GCL. The test plot was constructed a second time and the current response is more in keeping with the anticipated behaviour. Other than these slides, however, all of the other GCL plots appear to be stable.

If the internal stability of the GCLs continue, it can be assumed that the 2(H)-to-1(V) slopes have a factor-of-safety of 1.0 or greater. This being the case, the 3(H)-to-1(V) slopes have a factor-of-safety of 1.5 or greater. While this hypothesis is still being substantiated, it speaks well for the internal shear strength of the GCLs used in the study when properly installed. The project is ongoing as of, the writing of this paper.     

Instrumentation for monitoring field performance of the Cincinnati GCL test plots

Fourteen full-scale cover systems were constructed at a site in Cincinnati, Ohio, to understand better the strength capability of various GCLs as a component in cover systems. Four different geosynthetic clay liner (GCL) products were installed in full-scale cover systems on two different slopes. The main objective of the project was to monitor the internal shear strength of the GCLs over time. This required in-situ yet economic instrumentation. Instruments were designed, calibrated and installed in the test plots in order to monitor the moisture content of the subsoil and moisture content within the bentonite component of the GCL. In addition, total and differential deformations of the GCLs were monitored. The focus of'this paper is to report the details of instrumenting the GCLs rather than to report on specific GCL performance.     

On the chemo-thermo-hydro-mechanical behaviour of geological and engineered barriers

An overview of the recent findings about the chemo-hydro-mechanical behaviour of materials used for both geological and engineered barriers in nuclear waste disposal is presented, through some examples about the natural Boom Clay (BC) and compacted bentonite-based materials. For the natural BC, it was found that compression index identified from both oedometer and isotropic compression tests is similar and the compressibility of BC from the Mol site is higher than that of BC from the Essen site; the shear strength of Mol BC is also higher than that of the Essen BC, suggesting a significant effect of carbonates content; the thermal volume change is strongly overconsolidation ratio (OCR) dependent—low OCR values promote thermal contraction while high OCR values favour thermal dilation; the volume change behaviour is also strongly time dependent and this time dependent behaviour is governed by the stress level and temperature; the effect of pore-water salinity on the volume change behaviour can be significant when the smectite content is relatively high. For the bentonite-based materials, it was found that thermal contraction also occurs at low OCR values, but this is suction dependent—suction promotes thermal dilation. Under constant volume conditions, wetting results in a decrease of hydraulic conductivity, followed by an increase. This is found to be related to changes in macro-pores size—wetting induces a decrease of macro-pores size, followed by an increase due to the aggregates fissuring. The presence of technological voids can increase the hydraulic conductivity but does not influence the swelling pressure.     

Experimental research on water retention and gas permeability of compacted bentonite/sand mixtures

Highly compacted bentonite-based materials are often considered as buffer or sealing materials for deep high-level radioactive waste repositories. In situ, the initial state of bentonite-based materials is only partially saturated, which has a very high suction that will promote water absorption from the host rock. In addition, a gradient of water saturation will be formed between the external part and the central part of the compacted bentonite blocks. In this paper, water retention tests, under both constant-volume and free-swelling conditions, were performed to investigate the suction behavior of a compacted bentonite/sand mixture. In order to investigate the sealing ability of the partially saturated bentonite/sand mixture, gas permeability tests were also carried out under the in situ confining stress. It was found that the confining conditions have a limited effect on the water retention capacity of the compacted bentonite/sand mixture at lower levels of relative humidity (RH), while this influence is significant at higher RH levels. The results of gas permeability tests show that gas permeability is very sensitive to the water content and the confining pressure. When the sample (stable at RH=98%) was subjected to a in situ confining pressure (7–8 MPa), the gas permeability was very low (1.83×10^–14 m/s) which indicates that gas tightness can be obtained even though the sample is not fully saturated.     

Interface transmissivity of conventional and multicomponent GCLs for three permeants

A laboratory investigation of the interface transmissivity is reported for five different geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs) and a range of different geomembranes (GMBs) for a range of stresses from 10 to 150?kPa. The GCLs were prehydrated under normal stress before permeation. The GCLs examined comprised three multicomponent (a smooth coated, a smooth laminated, and textured coated) and two conventional (one with granular and one with powdered sodium bentonite) GCLs. The effect of a 4?mm circular defect in the coating of a multicomponent GCL directly below the 10?mm diameter hole in the GMB is investigated. The effect of GMB stiffness and texture is examined. Additionally, the effect of hydration and permeation of smooth coated GCL with highly saline solution and synthetic landfill leachate (SL3) is presented. It is shown that the 2-week interface transmissivity (θ_2-week) can be one to two orders of magnitude higher than steady-state interface transmissivity (θ _steady-state) at low stresses (10?kPa–50?kPa), whereas at high stresses (150?kPa) the variation is substantially less. For a smooth coated GCL hydrated and permeated with reverse osmosis (RO) water, GMB stiffness and texture has a limited effect on interface transmissivity when the coating is placed in contact with GMB at normal stresses of 10?kPa–150?kPa, whereas coating indentations result in much high interface transmissivity when placed in contact with GMB. GCL prehydration and permeation with highly saline solutions leads to higher interface transmissivity compared to RO water. With a 4.0?mm defect in the coating, the interface transmissivity between the coating and woven geotextile is higher than that between the coating and GMB for the stress levels and GCL examined.     

Experimental investigation of the effect of airgaps in preventing desiccation of bentonite in geosynthetic clay liners exposed to high temperatures

This paper investigates whether the introduction of an airgap above a composite liner made of a geomembrane (GMB) and a Geosynthetic Clay Liner (GCL) can decrease thermal loads on the GCL, reduce the risk of bentonite desiccation and/or help maintain its low hydraulic conductivity. A composite liner, subject to 20?kPa overburden load, over a well graded sand was subjected to a thermal gradient. In addition, to the reference base case in which no airgap was present, two designs included air gaps through the placement of a 10?mm and 20?mm-thick geocomposites (GC) on top of the GCL-GMB, respectively.Temperatures on top of the GCLs were found to be significantly reduced by the presence of air gaps, relative to the reference base case. All three designs resulted in GCL desiccation cracks at the end of the tests, due to the relatively high temperature gradients and low water retention of the subsoil, even in the presence of air gaps. However, X-Ray imaging revealed that crack patterns in bentonite samples from designs with air gaps were finer and narrower. Subsequent rehydration (and permeation tests) with distilled water indicated that significant self-healing of bentonite was in evidence in all three cases. However, while in the absence of an air gap the saturated hydraulic conductivity was found to be 2.8 times its pre-heating value, no significant increase was recorded for other two cases. X-Ray imaging of rehydrated samples confirmed that more effective healing had occurred in samples with an air gap.