A robust online energy management strategy for fuel cell/battery hybrid electric vehicles

Traditional optimization-based energy management strategies (EMSs) do not consider the uncertainty of driving cycle induced by the change of traffic conditions, this paper proposes a robust online EMS (ROEMS) for fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles (FCHEV) to handle the uncertain driving cycles. The energy consumption model of the FCHEV is built by considering the power loss of fuel cell, battery, electric motor, and brake. An offline linear programming-based method is proposed to produce the benchmark solution. The ROEMS instantaneously minimizes the equivalent power of fuel cell and battery, where an equivalent efficiency of battery is defined as the efficiency of hydrogen energy transforming to battery energy. To control the state of charge of battery, two control coefficients are introduced to adjust the power of battery in objective function. Another penalty coefficient is used to amend the power of fuel cell, which reduces the load change of fuel cell so as to slow the degradation of fuel cell. The simulation results indicate that ROEMS has good performance in both fuel economy and load change control of fuel cell. The most important advantage of ROEMS is its robustness and adaptivity, because it almost produces the optimal solution without changing the control parameters when driving cycles are changed.     

Optimal vehicle control strategy of a fuel cell/battery hybrid city bus

In this article, an optimal vehicle control strategy based on a time-triggered controller area network (TTCAN) system for a polymer electrolyte membrane (PEM) fuel cell/nickel-metal hydride (Ni-MH) battery powered city bus is presented. Aiming at improving the fuel economy of the city bus, the control strategy comprises an equivalent consumption minimization strategy (ECMS) and a braking energy regeneration strategy (BERS). On the basis of the introduction of a battery equivalent hydrogen consumption model incorporating a charge-sustaining coefficient, an analytical solution to the equivalent consumption minimization problem is given. The proposed strategy has been applied in several city buses for the Beijing Olympic Games of 2008. Results of the “China city bus typical cycle” testing show that, the ECMS and the BERS lowered hydrogen consumption by 2.5% and 15.3% respectively, compared with a rule-based strategy. The BERS contributes much more than the ECMS to the fuel economy, because the fuel cell system does not leave much room for the optimal algorithm in improving the efficiency.     

An online prognostics-based health management strategy for fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles

As the energy transformation in the transportation sector is taking place driven by the development of fuel cell technologies, fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles become promising solutions owing to their long driving duration and zero emissions. However, the unsatisfied lifespan of fuel cells is an inevitable obstacle for their massive commercialization. This paper aims to propose an online adaptive prognostics-based health management strategy for fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles, which can improve the durability of the fuel cell thanks to online health monitoring. Here, particle filtering method is adapted for online fuel cell prognostics and the uncertainty of the predicted results is calculated based on the distribution of particles. A health management strategy is developed based on prognostics and a decision-making process is designed by considering the prognostics uncertainty through a decision fusion method. The obtained results show that the developed strategy has effectively improved the durability of the on-board fuel cell by up to 95.4%. Moreover, a sensitivity analysis of the prognostics occurrence frequency and probability calculation has also been conducted in this paper.     

Intelligent energy management strategy based on hierarchical approximate global optimization for plug-in fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles

The energy management strategy (EMS) is a key to reduce the equivalent hydrogen consumption and slow down fuel cell performance degradation of the plug-in fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles. Global optimal EMS based on the whole trip information can achieve the minimum hydrogen consumption, but it is difficult to apply in real driving. This paper tries to solve this problem with a novel hierarchical EMS proposed to realize the real-time application and approximate global optimization. The long-term average speed in each future trip segment is predicted by KNN, and the short-term speed series is predicted by a new model averaging method. The approximate global optimization is realized by introducing hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL), and the strategy within the speed forecast window is optimized by introducing upper confidence tree search (UCTS). The vehicle speed prediction and the proposed EMS have been verified using the collected real driving cycles. The results show that the proposed strategy can adapt to driving style changes through self-learning. Compared with the widely used rule-based strategy, it can evidently reduce hydrogen consumption by 6.14% and fuel cell start-stop times by 21.7% on average to suppress the aging of fuel cell. Moreover, its computation time is less than 0.447 s at each step, and combined with rolling optimization, it can be used for real-time application.     

Optimization based energy management strategy for fuel cell/battery/ultracapacitor hybrid vehicle considering fuel economy and fuel cell lifespan

Optimization of energy management strategy (EMS) for fuel cell/battery/ultracapacitor hybrid electrical vehicle (FCHEV) is primarily aimed on reducing fuel consumption. However, serious power fluctuation has effect on the durability of fuel cell, which still remains one challenging barrier for FCHEVs. In this paper, we propose an optimized frequency decoupling EMS using fuzzy control method to extend fuel cell lifespan and improve fuel economy for FCHEV. In the proposed EMS, fuel cell, battery and ultracapacitor are employed to supply low, middle and high-frequency components of required power, respectively. For accurately adjusting membership functions of proposed fuzzy controllers, genetic algorithm (GA) is adopted to optimize them considering multiple constraints on fuel cell power fluctuation and hydrogen consumption. The proposed EMS is verified by Advisor-Simulink and experiment bench. Simulation and experimental results confirm that the proposed EMS can effectively reduce hydrogen consumption in three typical drive cycles, limit fuel cell power fluctuation within 300 W/s and thus extend fuel cell lifespan.     

An innovative optimal power allocation strategy for fuel cell, battery and supercapacitor hybrid electric vehicle

An optimal design of a three-component hybrid fuel cell electric vehicle comprised of fuel cells, battery, and supercapacitors is presented. First, the benefits of using this hybrid combination are analyzed, and then the article describes an active power-flow control strategy from each energy source based on optimal control theory to meet the demand of different vehicle loads while optimizing total energy cost, battery life and other possible objectives at the same time. A cost function that minimizes the square error between the desired variable settings and the current sensed values is developed. A gain sequence developed compels the choice of power drawn from all devices to follow an optimal path, which makes trade-offs among different targets and minimizes the total energy spent. A new method is introduced to make the global optimization into a real-time based control. A model is also presented to simulate the individual energy storage systems and compare this invention to existing control strategies, the simulation results show that the total energy spent is well saved over the long driving cycles, also the fuel cell and batteries are kept operating in a healthy way.     

An improved energy management strategy for FC/UC hybrid electric vehicles propelled by motor-wheels

The hybridization of the fuel-cell electric-vehicle (FCEV) by a second energy source has the advantage of improving the system's dynamic response and efficiency. Indeed, an ultra-capacitor (UC) system used as an energy storage device fulfills the FC slowest dynamics during fast power transitions and recovers the braking energy. In FC/UC hybrid vehicles, the search for a suitable power management approach is one of the main objectives. In this paper, an improved control strategy managing the active power distribution between the two energy sources is proposed. The UC reference power is calculated through the DC link voltage regulation. For the FC power demand, an algorithm with five operating modes is developed. This algorithm, depending on the UC state of charge (SOC) and the vehicle speed level, minimizes the FC power demand transitions and therefore ameliorates its durability. The traction power is provided using two permanent magnetic synchronous motor-wheels to free more space in the vehicle. The models of the FC/UC vehicle system parts and the control strategy are developed using MATLAB software. Simulation results show the effectiveness of the proposed energy management strategy.     

A new cost-minimizing power-allocating strategy for the hybrid electric bus with fuel cell/battery health-aware control

The two primary challenges preventing the commercialization of fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles (FCHEV) are their high cost and limited lifespan. Improper use usage can could also hasten the breakdown of proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC). This paper proposes a new cost-minimizing power-allocating technique with fuel cell/battery health-aware control to optimize the economic potential of fuel cell/battery hybrid buses. The proposed framework quantifies the fuel cell (FC) deterioration of the whole working zone in a real hybrid electric bus using a long short-term memory network (LSTM), which reduces the time required to get the key lifetime parameters. A new FC lifespan model is embedded into the control framework, together with a battery aging model, to balance hydrogen consumption and energy source durability. In addition, in the speed prediction step, an enhanced online Markov prediction approach with stochastic disturbances is presented to increase the forecast accuracy for future disturbances. Finally, comparative analysis is used to verify the efficacy of the suggested approach, which shows that when compared to the benchmark method, the proposed strategy may extend the FC lifetime and lower operating costs by 5.04% and 3.76%, respectively.     

Hierarchical energy management for PV/hydrogen/battery island DC microgrid

This research presents an optimum design scheme and a hierarchical energy management strategy for an island PV/hydrogen/battery hybrid DC microgrid (MG). In order to efficiently utilize this DC MG, the optimum structure and sizing scheme are designed by HOMER pro (Hybrid Optimization of Multiple Energy Resources) software. The designed structure of hydrogen MG includes a PV generation, a battery as well as a hydrogen subsystem which composes a fuel cell (FC) system, an electrolyzer and hydrogen tank. To improve the robustness and economy of this DC MG, this study schedules a hierarchical energy management method, including the local control layer and the system control layer. In the local control layer, the subsystems in this DC MG are controlled based on their inherent operating characteristics. And the equivalent consumption minimization strategy (ECMS) is applied in the system control layer, the power flow between the battery and FC is allocated to minimum the fuel consumption. An island DC MG hardware-in-loop (HIL) Simulink platform is established by RT-LAB real-time simulator, and the simulation results are presented to validate the proposed energy management strategy.     

Lifespan-consciousness and minimum-consumption coupled energy management strategy for fuel cell hybrid vehicles via deep reinforcement learning

Energy management strategy (EMS) based on optimized deep reinforcement learning plays a critical role in minimizing fuel consumption and prolonging the fuel cell stack lifespan for fuel cell hybrid vehicles. The deep Q-learning (DQL) and deep deterministic policy gradient (DDPG) algorithms with priority experience replay are proposed in this research. The factors of fuel economy and power fluctuation are incorporated into the multi-objective reward functions to decline the fuel consumption and extend the lifetime of fuel cell stack. In addition, the degradation rate is introduced to reflect the lifetime of fuel cell stack. Furthermore, compared to the referenced optimally energy management strategy (dynamic planning), the DQL-based and DDPG-based EMS with prioritized experience replay (DQL-PER, DDPG-PER) are evaluated in hydrogen consumption and cumulative degradation of fuel cell stack under four driving cycles, FTP75, US06-2, NEDC and LA92-2, respectively. The training results reveal that the DQL-PER-based EMS performances better under FTP75 and US06-2 driving cycles, whereas DDPG-PER-based EMS has better performance under NEDC driving cycle, which provide a potential for applying the proposed algorithm into multi-cycles.     

A control architecture to coordinate energy management with trajectory tracking control for fuel cell/battery hybrid unmanned aerial vehicles

Fuel cell/battery hybrid energy storage system (HESS) powered unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) has the outstanding advantage of long endurance time. Trajectory tracking motion is a commonly used task execution mode of UAVs, especially in autonomous UAVs. This study aims at developing a control architecture to coordinate energy management with trajectory tracking control for fuel cell/battery hybrid UAVs. Its position tracking control adopts model predictive control (MPC) and an extended state observer to eliminate the modeling errors and effect of interference. The attitude tracking control adopts an auto-disturbance rejection controller having a quick response. The obtained control parameters are given as an input to the energy management block. Energy management strategies (EMSs) based on online dynamic programming and hierarchical MPC have been proposed. The results obtained from a simulation show that the proposed trajectory tracking control architecture can track the target trajectory stably with a small tracking error. The tracking performance is stable under interference. Experimental results show that dynamic programming is solved online with good control performance. Compared to ordinary EMSs, dynamic programming and hierarchical MPC can increase endurance time by 2.69% and 1.27%, respectively. The proposed control architecture verifies the coordination of energy management and trajectory tracking control, and prospected the advantages of the combination of fuel cell and autonomous driving for long endurance UAVs in the future.     

Comparison among various energy management strategies for reducing hydrogen consumption in a hybrid fuel cell/supercapacitor/battery system

The aim of this study is to introduce a comprehensive comparison of various energy management strategies of fuel cell/supercapacitor/battery storage systems. These strategies are utilized to manage the energy demand response of hybrid systems, in an optimal way, under highly fluctuating load condition. Two novel strategies based on salp swarm algorithm (SSA) and mine-blast optimization are proposed. The outcomes of these strategies are compared with commonly used strategies like fuzzy logic control, classical proportional integral control, the state machine, equivalent fuel consumption minimization, maximization, external energy maximization, and equivalent consumption minimization. Hydrogen fuel economy and overall efficiency are used for the comparison of these different strategies. Results demonstrate that the proposed SSA management strategy performed best compared with all other used strategies in terms of hydrogen fuel economy and overall efficiency. The minimum consumed hydrogen and maximum efficiency are found 19.4 gm and 85.61%, respectively.     

Adaptive energy management for fuel cell hybrid power system with power slope constraint and variable horizon speed prediction

An adaptive energy management strategy (EMS) is proposed to improve the economy and reliability of the fuel cell vehicle. Firstly, a variable horizon speed prediction method based on the principal component analysis and the K-means clustering is constructed. Then, an adaptive equivalent consumption minimization strategy (AECMS) with power slope constraints was designed to minimize the hydrogen consumption while ensuring reliability. Finally, a proportional-integral controller is used to track the air flow and pressure of the fuel cell engine (FCE) under energy distribution. Simulation results under West Virginia University Suburban (WVUSUB) show that the proposed strategy can improve the speed prediction accuracy by 2.80% and 25.57%, and reduce the hydrogen consumption by 2.79% and 2.66%, respectively, compared with the fixed 12 s and 15 s horizon. Moreover, the control error of oxygen excess ratio and the cathode pressure under energy distribution are 0.0102 (0.51%) and 189.4 Pa (0.0935%), respectively, indicating better reliability than the strategy without constraint.     

Experimental investigation on the online fuzzy energy management of hybrid fuel cell/battery power system for UAVs

The hybrid powerplant combining a fuel cell and a battery has become one of the most promising alternative power systems for electric unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs). To enhance the fuel efficiency and battery service life, highly effective and robust online energy management strategies are needed in real applications.In this work, an energy management system is designed to control the hybrid fuel cell and battery power system for electric UAVs. To reduce the weight, only one programmable direct-current to direct-current (dcdc) converter is used as the critical power split component to implement the power management strategy. The output voltage and current of the dcdc is controlled by an independent energy management controller. An executable process of online fuzzy energy management strategy is proposed and established. According to the demand power and battery state of charge, the online fuzzy energy management strategy produces the current command for the dcdc to directly control the output current of the fuel cell and to indirectly control the charge/discharge current of the battery based on the power balance principle.Another two online strategies, the passive control strategy and the state machine strategy, are also employed to compare with the proposed online fuzzy strategy in terms of the battery management and fuel efficiency. To evaluate and compare the feasibility of the online energy management strategies in application, experiments with three types of missions are carried out using the hybrid power system test-bench, which consists of a commercial fuel cell EOS600, a Lipo battery, a programmable dcdc converter, an energy management controller, and an electric load. The experimental investigation shows that the proposed online fuzzy strategy prefers to use the most power from the battery and consumes the least amount of hydrogen fuel compared with the other two online energy management strategies.     

Towards health-aware energy management strategies in fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles: A review

An energy management strategy (EMS) is responsible for distributing the power between the electrochemical power sources of a fuel cell hybrid electric vehicle (FCHEV) with a view to minimizing the hydrogen consumption and maximizing the lifetime of the system. However, the energetic characteristics of the electrochemical devices (fuel cell, battery, and supercapacitor) are time-varying due to the influence of ageing, and different ambient and operating conditions. Any drift in the characteristics of the power sources can lead to the mismanagement of an EMS. According to the literature, ignorance of health adaptation can increase the hydrogen consumption from almost 6.5%–24% depending on the EMS. Therefore, it is necessary to develop a strategy which is aware of the actual state of the components while conducting the power split. Health monitoring techniques are potential candidates to deal with the uncertainties arising from the mentioned factors. In this respect, this paper first puts forward a concise review of the general modeling techniques which are essential for developing precise health monitoring techniques and in turn EMSs. Subsequently, the utilized methods for prognosis, diagnosis, and health state tracking of each of the mentioned power sources in a FCHEV are introduced. Then, a new taxonomy for the classification of the EMSs based on their health-awareness is proposed based on which three categories of prognostic-based, diagnostic-based, and systemic EMSs are formed. Each category is thoroughly explained, and a state-of-the-art review of these health-aware EMSs is presented. Finally, future perspectives of this new line of research and development are discussed before drawing a conclusion.     

Multi-mode control strategy for fuel cell electric vehicles regarding fuel economy and durability

A proton electrolyte membrane (PEM) fuel cell system and a Li-ion battery (LIB) are two power sources in a fuel cell electric vehicle (FCEV). The fuel cell system is composed of a fuel cell stack and subsystems for air/hydrogen supply and cooling water. The operation procedure of the fuel cell system can be generally separated into several processes, e.g. starting up, normal/abnormal working and shutting down. In this paper, a multi-mode real-time control strategy for a FCEV is proposed. The strategy is established based on three typical processes (starting up, normal working, shutting down) of the fuel cell system, taking the fuel economy and system durability into consideration. The strategy is applied into a platform vehicle for the 12th 5-year project of “the next generation technologies of fuel cell city buses”. Experiments of the “China city bus typical cycle” on a test bench for the bus were carried out. Results show that, the fuel economy is 7.6 kg (100 km)⁻¹ in the battery charge-sustaining status. In a practical situation, a total driving mileage of more than 270 km can be achieved. Cycle testing also showed that, the degradation rate of the fuel cell was reduced to half of the original level. No performance degradation of the LIB system was observed in the cycling test.     

A wavelet-fuzzy logic based energy management strategy for a fuel cell/battery/ultra-capacitor hybrid vehicular power system

Due to increasing concerns on environmental pollution and depleting fossil fuels, fuel cell (FC) vehicle technology has received considerable attention as an alternative to the conventional vehicular systems. However, a FC system combined with an energy storage system (ESS) can display a preferable performance for vehicle propulsion. As the additional ESS can fulfill the transient power demand fluctuations, the fuel cell can be downsized to fit the average power demand without facing peak loads. Besides, braking energy can be recovered by the ESS. This study focuses on a vehicular system powered by a fuel cell and equipped with two secondary energy storage devices: battery and ultra-capacitor (UC). However, an advanced energy management strategy is quite necessary to split the power demand of a vehicle in a suitable way for the on-board power sources in order to maximize the performance while promoting the fuel economy and endurance of hybrid system components. In this study, a wavelet and fuzzy logic based energy management strategy is proposed for the developed hybrid vehicular system. Wavelet transform has great capability for analyzing signals consisting of instantaneous changes like a hybrid electric vehicle (HEV) power demand. Besides, fuzzy logic has a quite suitable structure for the control of hybrid systems. The mathematical and electrical models of the hybrid vehicular system are developed in detail and simulated using MATLAB^®, Simulink^® and SimPowerSystems^® environments.     

Adaptive supervisory control strategy of a fuel cell/battery-powered city bus

This paper presents an adaptive supervisory control strategy for a fuel cell/battery-powered city bus to fulfill the complex road conditions in Beijing bus routes. An equivalent consumption minimization strategy (ECMS) is firstly proposed to optimize the fuel economy. The adaptive supervisory control strategy is exploited based on this, incorporating an estimating algorithm for the vehicle accessorial power, an algorithm for the battery charge-sustaining and a Recursive Least Squares (RLS) algorithm for fuel cell performance identification. Finally, an adaptive supervisory controller (ASC) considering the fuel consumption minimization, the battery charge-sustaining and the fuel cell durability has been implemented within the hybrid city buses. Results in the “China city bus typical cycle” testing and the demonstrational program of Beijing bus routes are presented, demonstrating that this approach provides an improvement of fuel economy along with robustness and ease of implementation. However, the fuel cell system does not leave much room for the optimal strategy to promote the fuel economy. Benefits may also result in a prolongation of the fuel cell working life, which needs to be verified in future.     

An energy management strategy based on dynamic power factor for fuel cell/battery hybrid locomotive

In order to efficiently absorb more regenerative braking energy which sustains much longer compared with the conventional vehicle, and guarantee the safety of the hybrid system under the actual driving cycle of locomotive, an energy management control based on dynamic factor strategy is proposed for a scale-down locomotive system which consists of proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) and battery pack. The proposed strategy which has self-adaption function for different driving cycles aims to achieve the less consumption of hydrogen and higher efficiency of the hybrid system. The experimental results demonstrate that the proposed strategy is able to maintain the charge state of battery (SOC) better than Equivalent Consumption Minimization Strategy (ECMS), and the proposed strategy could keep the change trend of SOC, which the final SOC is closed to the target value regardless of the initial SOC of battery. Moreover, the hydrogen consumption has been reduced by 0.86g and the efficiency of overall system has been raised of 2% at least than ECMS under the actual driving cycle through the proposed strategy. Therefore, the proposed strategy could improve the efficiency of system by diminishing the conversion process of energy outputted by fuel cell.     

A comparison of rule-based and model predictive controller-based power management strategies for fuel cell/battery hybrid vehicles considering degradation

Traditional power management systems for hybrid vehicles often focus on the optimization of one particular cost factor, such as fuel consumption, under specific driving scenarios. The cost factor is usually based on the beginning-of-life performance of system components. Typically, such strategies do not account for the degradation of the different components of the system over their lifetimes. This study incorporates the effect of fuel cell and battery degradation within their cost factors and investigates the impact of different power management strategies on fuel cell/battery loads and thus on the operating cost over the vehicle's lifetime. A simple rule-based power management system was compared with a model predictive controller (MPC) based system under a connected vehicle scenario (where the future vehicle speed is known a priori within a short time horizon). The combined cost factor consists of hydrogen consumption and the degradation of both the fuel cell stack and the battery. The results show that the rule-based power management system actually performs better and achieves lower lifetime cost compared to the MPC system even though the latter contains more information about the drive cycle. This result is explained by examining the changing dynamics of the three cost factors over the vehicle's lifetime. These findings reveal that a limited knowledge of traffic information might not be as useful for the power management of certain fuel cell/battery hybrid vehicles when degradation is taken into consideration, and a simple tuned rule-based controller is adequate to minimize the lifetime cost.